数学家传记
爱德华·洛希是19世纪法国数学家和天文学家,整个职业生涯都在蒙彼利埃大学工作。他因今天所称的爱德华·洛希瓣、等势面和爱德华·洛希极限而闻名,该极限给出了行星到卫星将被撕裂成环的距离。
爱德华·洛希是Arthur Pierre François Esprit 洛希(1785-1862)和Pauline Angélique Auguy(1800-1877)的儿子。Arthur Roche于1785年5月21日出生在蒙彼利埃,是Pierre Roche和Agathe Élisabeth Crassous的儿子。他成为埃罗省省长顾问,后来成为秘书长。他于1819年11月22日在蒙彼利埃与Pauline Auguy结婚。她于1800年4月22日出生在埃罗省的Saint-Pargoire,是地主André 洛希 Auguy和Françoise Antoinette Guillaumette Arnal的女儿。Arthur和Pauline Roche有三个孩子:洛希,生于1820年10月17日,即本传记的主人公;Sosthenes 洛希,生于1823年1月18日,于1824年9月28日一岁时去世;以及Arthur Roche,生于1835年8月9日。Arthur Roche Jr(1835-1910)也成为了一名数学家,我们将在下面稍作介绍。
他出身于一个有着悠久学术成功传统的家庭,家族中多人成为蒙彼利埃大学的教授。当他在蒙彼利埃中学洛希学习时,就展现出非凡的才华,几乎可以肯定他将延续这一传统。然而,不太明显的是他将专攻哪个领域,因为他在文学和科学方面同样才华横溢。他在两个领域都赢得了最高奖项,他的老师们都注意到,他的卓越能力和对学习的热情将使他在任一领域都大有作为。只有当他接触到更高等的数学主题时,他才感到这正不可抗拒地将他引向那个方向。对于像洛希这样杰出的学生来说,巴黎的大大学是显而易见的选择,他全力以赴准备入学考试。
1840年,他从蒙彼利埃中学毕业后,被巴黎综合理工学院录取,他的刻苦努力似乎得到了回报。然而,由于他天生体质虚弱,刻苦努力已导致健康问题,他的父母觉得在巴黎综合理工学院学习的压力可能太大。1840年,他没有去巴黎,而是进入蒙彼利埃大学,热衷于学习数学和物理科学。他在蒙彼利埃理学院选修了约瑟夫·热尔岗、Pierre Lenthéric(1793-1849)和路易·安托万-Jérôme Balard(1802-1876)讲授的课程。约瑟夫·热尔岗是几何学专家,但也撰写了分析、静力学、天文学和光学方面的论文。Lenthéric于1815年被任命为蒙彼利埃中学初等数学教授,1821年改教物理学,然后从1827年起在蒙彼利埃理学院任教。他先教授超越数学,1830年起成为特殊数学教授。他还于1830年至1833年担任天文学讲席,然后在1833年成为超越数学正教授。Balard是一位化学家,以发现溴而闻名。他于1833年至1843年担任蒙彼利埃理学院化学教授,之后成为索邦大学化学教授。
在蒙彼利埃理学院还有一位教授影响了洛希,即Jean Nicolas Legrand(1796-1871)。Legrand曾是巴黎高等师范学校的学生,在1832年被任命为图卢兹理学院讲师之前,曾在杜埃、兰斯、阿维尼翁、南锡和贝桑松担任物理学教授。他于1837年来到蒙彼利埃,被任命到理学院,并于1841年成为天文学教授。他增强了洛希将数学应用于天文学问题的兴趣。
洛希于1844年从蒙彼利埃理学院毕业,获得博士学位。他为博士学位提交了两篇论文,一篇是数学物理论文,题为Sur la distribution de la chaleur dans une sphère Ⓣ(论球体中的热分布),另一篇是天文学论文,题为Sur la figure des planètes Ⓣ(论行星的形状)。让我们引用这两篇论文的引言。第一篇开头如下:-
我们即将处理的问题的方程由西莫恩·德尼·泊松在其《热的理论》第十章中给出。那里指出了要使用的积分方法;但解只对球体均匀的情形作了展开。
当球体是非均质的,但仍然使得在每个球层整个范围内温度相同时,问题就归结为两个变量的线性二阶偏差分方程的积分。用通常的方法进行这种积分,会得到一个只能在小数特殊情形下才能积分的微分方程,而且即使能得到函数的表达式,也难于发现它的变化过程和主要性质。
因此,有必要通过直接考虑这个微分方程,找到一种方法来认识它隐含确定的函数的性质。这正是M 雅克·夏尔·弗朗索瓦·施图姆在他出色的《论线性二阶微分方程》中所做的,在那里,他用一种既优雅又富有成效的方法,建立了这些积分的奇妙性质。同一位几何学家在他的《论一类偏微分方程》中展示了这些性质的用途。我们还应该提到M 约瑟夫·刘维尔关于同一主题的几篇非常有趣的论文。
基于这些不同的工作,我们将研究球体中的热分布,其中温度在每一时刻只依赖于到中心的距离。然后我们将从一般公式推出关于均匀球体的那些公式,并指出它们在地球内部和表面热量运动问题中的应用。
天文学论文开头如下:-
对于具有旋转运动的均匀流体质量,寻找平衡图形是一个困难的问题,只有当假定该图形与球体差别很小时才能完全解决。在这种情况下,只有一个平衡图形,即两极扁平的旋转椭球体。
为了证明这个重要命题,皮埃尔·西蒙·拉普拉斯使用了《天体力学》第三卷中的两种方法。第一种基于级数展开,他将其引入分析,并在球体吸引问题、潮汐问题和热理论中反复出现。这位著名的几何学家承认可以用这类级数表示两个变量的任何函数,这个定理后来由西莫恩·德尼·泊松先验地证明了。
由于担心这个假设可能会使他的分析结果受到怀疑,皮埃尔·西蒙·拉普拉斯认为有必要独立于级数的使用来证明所讨论的命题。正如M 约瑟夫·刘维尔所指出的,这第二个证明是不完整的,他提供了一个严格的证明。西莫恩·德尼·泊松提供了另一个证明,但这个证明仍然不精确,正如我们将看到的。
我们在这里将假定,除了其分子间的相互吸引外,流体质量还受到一个位于其中心、与距离平方成反比的力的作用;这隐含地包括了流体质量覆盖着一个密度与其自身不同的球体的情形。
1842年7月8日星期五发生过一次日全食,全食带经过米兰、都灵、马赛、蒙彼利埃、萨拉戈萨和马德里。洛希观测了这次日食,并发表了一份观测报告,其中包括对太阳周围红色突出物的测量。弗朗索瓦·阿拉戈对洛希的报告印象非常深刻,并在自己的报告中以热烈的措辞引用了它。阿拉戈为洛希提供了巴黎天文台免费学生的名额,1844年在蒙彼利埃完成博士学位后,洛希前往巴黎。在巴黎天文台,洛希在埃尔韦·奥古斯特·艾蒂安·阿尔班·法耶(1814-1902)的指导下学习实用天文学。法耶曾在巴黎综合理工学院学习,1834年未完成课程便离校,接受了弗朗索瓦·阿拉戈在巴黎天文台的职位邀请。1843年11月22日,他发现了一颗轨道周期约为7.5年的周期彗星,现命名为4P/法耶。这为他带来了国际声誉,他于1844年获得拉朗德奖,并于同年当选为法国科学院。除了在天文台工作外,洛希还在索邦大学或法兰西学院旁听了奥古斯丁·路易·柯西、于尔班·勒维耶、夏尔-欧仁·德洛奈、约瑟夫·刘维尔和雅克·夏尔·弗朗索瓦·施图姆的讲座。
1847年底,洛希回到蒙彼利埃,并于1847年11月17日与玛丽·于尔叙勒·阿梅莉·里加尔结婚。玛丽·里加尔(1828-1847)于1828年5月29日出生在蒙彼利埃,父亲是弗朗索瓦·罗克·里加尔,母亲是卡罗琳·维尔日妮·布朗希。不幸的是,玛丽·里加尔在婚礼庆祝期间感染了肺炎,于1847年11月23日,即婚后六天去世。约瑟夫·布西内斯克写道[2]:-
……从那时起,只有对配得上他的母亲、父亲和兄弟的最温柔的感情,才能排遣他内心的孤独。我相信,从那天起,他就再也笑不出来了,尽管他仍保持着那种和蔼微笑的习惯,那是他略带忧郁的善良的表达,他所有的学生都熟悉。
1849年,洛希被任命为蒙彼利埃大学的授课教师,三年后,即1852年,他被任命为数学教授。1848年,洛希发表了他的前四篇天文学论文,全部发表在《蒙彼利埃科学与文学科学院回忆录》上。它们是:Observation de l'éclipse de soleil du 9 octobre 1847Ⓣ(对1847年10月9日日食的观测);Mémoire sur la loi de la densité à l'intérieur de la terreⓉ(关于地球内部密度定律的回忆录);Mémoire sur la figure de la terreⓉ(关于地球形状的回忆录);以及Calcul de l'inégalité parallactique du mouvement de la luneⓉ(月球运动视差不等式的计算)。
洛希关于太阳系的许多工作汇集在[16]中。他给出了以下引言:-
我对天体形状以及围绕它们的大气中水平层排列的研究,引导我得出了一些适用于太阳、其大气以及我们所知的各种行星借以形成的渐进凝聚过程的结果。我打算在此汇集我先前工作中与这些问题相关的结论,并展示它们如何证实、阐明或修改皮埃尔·西蒙·拉普拉斯的宇宙起源理论。
本回忆录将讨论与太阳系有关的各种问题;但是,鉴于主题的困难,读者不会惊讶地发现,在许多点上只有概览。
洛希今天主要通过洛希瓣和洛希极限而被记住。洛希瓣是双星系统中围绕恒星的等势面,其中物质被引力束缚在恒星上。洛希极限是行星到卫星的距离,在该距离处卫星将被撕成小块,形成围绕行星的环。Martin Solc在[17]中写道关于洛希瓣:-
洛希致力于通常不在他那个时代主流天文学研究范围内的主题。他研究了旋转流体体的平衡图形,该流体体受到由另一个天体引起的外部引力作用。这个条件对于确定像双星这样一对天体周围的等势面极其重要。当一个(或两个)组件呈现泪滴形状时,如此填充的空间被称为洛希瓣。
Iwan P Williams在[20]中写道关于洛希极限:-
洛希([12],[13],[14])对与旋转流体的变形和裂变相关的问题表现出一些兴趣,但与他名字相关联的洛希极限的工作涉及通过假设卫星的质量损失形成土星环([15],[16])。该卫星被认为尺寸很小,不变形土星,也不接触,与地球-月球问题中假设的情况相反。土星和卫星的引力场都被视为点质量,洛希考虑粒子从卫星表面离土星最近的点损失。该卫星还被有效地假设为面向土星,尽管洛希实际上没有假设卫星的任何东西,只是将要损失的第三体保持在连接土星和卫星的线上直到损失。... 洛希极限实际上为次级天体能够接近主天体并在一组非常理想化的条件下保持稳定的最近距离设定了限制。特别是,假设次级天体在圆形轨道上运动并保持面向配置。实际上,几乎没有次级天体在圆形轨道上运动,面向配置也远非常见。
在[5]中,Zdenĕk Kopal将洛希的工作置于背景中:-
早在[洛希问题]出现并几乎成为本世纪下半叶双星天文学中的代名词之前,天文学家就已清楚地意识到它们的存在,这可以追溯到——因而得名于——法国数学家洛希 亚伯拉罕·阿德里安·艾伯特 洛希(1820-1883)。诚然,它们的根源在我们这门学科的历史上要久远得多;因为——通过它们与三体问题能量积分的联系——它们的许多性质已为德国数学家卡尔·古斯塔夫·雅各布·雅可比(1804-1851)所知,这些性质有时仍与他的名字联系在一起。然而实际上,其性质可追溯到18世纪约瑟夫·拉格朗日(1736-1813)的工作,事实上还可追溯到莱昂哈德·欧拉(1707-1789)——从而追溯到艾萨克·牛顿(1642-1727)时代微积分在动力天文学中的早期应用。然而,我们这门科学中所有这些伟大人物所关注的某些问题……仅仅是从质点力学的观点出发(即单个质点在时间过程中的运动);它们与双星天文学问题的关联被掩盖了,主要原因是当时天空中已知不存在双星(或者至少不存在密近双星)。然而,对与引力偶极子相关的等势面这一特殊情形的研究(密近引力偶极子相关的能量——能量积分约化为零速度面,或者更确切地说,约化为速度分量平方小到可以忽略的曲面)——一直是E A 洛希的历史任务;因此,将这些永久地与他的名字联系在一起是非常恰当的。
洛希的工作今天被视为极为重要,但在他生前却大多被忽视。Kopal提出,洛希在蒙彼利埃工作,远离天文学研究的主要区域,这可能对科学有利,但对他自己的声誉不利。Kopal写道,也许如果他是在巴黎工作,他的创新思想会被主流天文学家贬斥。他的声誉不佳,这一点可以从他1883年未能当选巴黎科学院院士一事看出。他已于1873年12月被选为通讯院士,但当约瑟夫·刘维尔于1882年9月去世时,科学院天文学部出现了一个空缺。费利克斯·蒂斯朗提名洛希填补这一空缺,并于1883年4月16日举行了选举。在投出的56票中,只有一票投给了洛希——这一定是费利克斯·蒂斯朗的票。
你可以阅读费利克斯·蒂斯朗为支持他提名洛希填补THIS LINK空缺而写的报告。
Kopal写道[5]:-
……其余院士(无疑是想避免将他选为与他们同等之人这一不公正之举)投票给了其他人,那些人的名字都已被遗忘,他们的工作也如死羊肉一般毫无生气。……也许,承认洛希对现代天体物理学贡献的根本性质之所以被延迟,主要原因是他那个时代对恒星内部结构的无知程度;因为即使在洛希去世之时,像儒勒·昂利·庞加莱这样水准的学者仍然认为,为了在此基础之上允许的数学简化,把恒星视为均匀的(有时甚至是不可压缩的!)自引力球体并非不合理。恒星的实际结构必定与这样的模型相去甚远,这一点直到20世纪初才开始显露出来……
洛希知道自己的名字已被提出来竞选科学院天文学部的院士,但几乎可以肯定他不会知道选举结果,因为他在投票举行仅两天后就因胸部感染去世了。
他的基督教信仰在他临终的病中支撑着他[2]:-
死亡并没有让他感到意外。长期以来,他已在践行基督教美德和简单信仰的宗教活动中,找到了与对更美好生活和更完全光明的希望相连的一切慰藉——那光明胜过在此尘世既令我们欢欣又扰乱我们摇摆理性的光。他从那里汲取力量,顺从地忍受那顽固咳嗽的折磨,这咳嗽正逐渐耗尽他的生命。在接受了教会的临终圣事后,他毫不畏缩地面对自己至高时刻的来临。
我们在上文提到了洛希的兄弟Arthur Roche,并承诺提供更多信息。Arthur Roche也成为了一名数学家,其职业生涯的大部分时间都在蒙彼利埃中学担任数学教授。约瑟夫·布西内斯克曾是蒙彼利埃中学的学生,他写道,Arthur Roche[2]:-
……在1859年10月和11月,通过几节课完成了我的理科业士学位考试准备。
愿[洛希的同事在他去世时表达的]一致哀悼之情能减轻他兄弟的痛苦;请允许我在结尾时把这些篇章献给他,因为他本人也是一位优秀的教授,尽管身处更平凡的领域,但凭此他也赢得了我感激的权利。
然而,关于Arthur Roche存在很多混淆。讣告[8]和[9]都是为Arthur Roche而写,并正确地说他在蒙彼利埃中学任教。然而,它们给出了洛希的科学成就,而且是在洛希去世后不久、Arthur Roche去世前27年写的!显然,两篇讣告都把两兄弟弄混了。当然,[9]声称其信息来自[19],我们注意到在[19]中,洛希只被称为“M 洛希”。
最后,让我们引用约瑟夫·布西内斯克关于在蒙彼利埃理学院选修洛希课程时所写的内容来评论洛希作为教师的表现[2]:-
作为蒙彼利埃理学院的学生,我有幸在1860年和1861年跟随洛希学习无穷小分析和力学课程,听课者们一致赞赏他的清晰性和富有感染力的热情。我尤其能在各种场合体会到他的善良之卓越。例如,我无法忘记他的善意,当他欢迎我并鼓励我的最初努力时,那时我仅有一点特殊数学的涉猎,由他的弟弟M Arthur Roche介绍给他,我向他表达了将一生献给科学研究的愿望。
2006年,月球背面的一座陨石坑以洛希命名。火星卫星火卫一上也有一座以他命名的陨石坑。
Édouard Roche was the son of Arthur Pierre François Esprit Roche (1785-1862) and Pauline Angélique Auguy (1800-1877). Arthur Roche had been born in Montpellier on 21 May 1785, a son of Pierre Roche and Agathe Élisabeth Crassous. He became an advisor and then secretary general of the prefecture of Hérault. He married Pauline Auguy on 22 November 1819 in Montpellier. She had been born in Saint-Pargoire, Hérault on 22 April 1800, a daughter of the landowner André Édouard Auguy and Françoise Antoinette Guillaumette Arnal. Arthur and Pauline Roche had three children: Édouard Roche, born 17 October 1820, the subject of this biography; Sosthenes Roche, born 18 January 1823, died when one year old on 28 September 1824; and Arthur Roche, born 9 August 1835. Arthur Roche Jr (1835-1910) also became a mathematician and we will say a little more about him below.
Coming from a family who had a long tradition of academic success, several becoming professors at the University of Montpellier, when he was studying at Montpellier Lycée Édouard Roche showed that his exceptional talents were almost certainly going to have him continue in that tradition. What was less obvious, however, was the area in which he would specialise since he was equally talented in literature and science. He won the top prizes in both and his teachers all noted that his great ability and also his enthusiasm for studying would lead him to achieve much in either topic. Only when he reached the more advanced mathematical topics did he feel that this was drawing him irresistibly in that direction. The Grandes Écoles of Paris were the obvious choice for an outstanding student such as Roche, and he put all his efforts into studying for the preparatory examinations.
In 1840, having graduated from the Montpellier Lycée, his hard work seemed to have paid off when he was accepted to study at the École Polytechnique in Paris. The hard work had, however, led to health problems since he had naturally delicate health, and his parents felt that the stress of studying at the École Polytechnique might prove too much. Instead of going to Paris, he entered the University of Montpellier in 1840 enthusiastic for studying mathematics and physical sciences. He took courses taught by Joseph Diez Gergonne, Pierre Lenthéric (1793-1849) and Antoine-Jérôme Balard (1802-1876) at the Faculty of Sciences in Montpellier. Gergonne was an expert in geometry but he also wrote papers on analysis, statics, astronomy, and optics. Lenthéric had been appointed professor of elementary mathematics at the Montpellier Lycée in 1815, changed to teach physics in 1821, then taught at the Faculty of Sciences of Montpellier from 1827. First he taught transcendental mathematics, then became professor of special mathematics from 1830. He also filled the chair of astronomy from 1830 to 1833, then in 1833 became full professor of transcendental mathematics. Balard was a chemist famed as the discoverer of bromine. He was professor of chemistry at the Faculty of Sciences of Montpellier from 1833 to 1843 when he became professor of chemistry at the Sorbonne.
There was one other professor at the Faculty of Sciences in Montpellier who influenced Roche, namely Jean Nicolas Legrand (1796-1871). Legrand was a student at the École Normale and had been a professor of physics in Douai, Reims, Avignon, Nancy and Besançon before being appointed as a lecturer at the Faculty of Sciences in Toulouse in 1832. He came to Montpellier in 1837 when appointed to the Faculty of Sciences where he became the Professor of Astronomy in 1841. He increased Roche's interest in applying mathematics to problems in astronomy.
Roche graduated with a doctorate from the Faculty of Sciences of Montpellier in 1844. For his doctorate he presented two theses, namely a mathematical physics thesis with title Sur la distribution de la chaleur dans une sphère Ⓣ, and an astronomy thesis with title Sur la figure des planètes Ⓣ. Let us quote from the introduction to both theses. The first begins as follows:-
The equations for the problem we are about to address were given by Poisson in his 'Theory of Heat', Chapter X. The integration procedure to be used is indicated there; but the solution is developed only for the case where the sphere is homogeneous.
When the sphere is heterogeneous, but nevertheless such that the temperature is the same throughout the entire extent of each spherical layer, the problem depends on the integration of a linear, second-order partial difference equation in two variables. This integration leads, using ordinary methods, to a differential equation that can only be integrated in a small number of particular cases, and even when the expression for the function can be obtained, it is difficult to discover its progression and its principal properties.
It was therefore necessary to find, through the direct consideration of this differential equation, a means of recognising the nature of the function it implicitly determines. This is what M Sturm did in his fine 'Memoir on Linear Second-Order Differential Equations', where, using a method as elegant as it was fruitful, he established the curious properties of these integrals. The same geometer demonstrated, in his 'Memoir on a Class of Partial Differential Equations', the use that can be made of these properties. We should also mention several very interesting memoirs by M Liouville on the same subject.
Based on these various works, we will study the distribution of heat in a sphere, where the temperature depends at each instant only on the distance from the centre. We will then deduce from the general formulas those relating to the homogeneous sphere, and we will indicate their use in the question of the movement of heat within and on the surface of the Earth.
The astronomy thesis begins as follows:-
The search for equilibrium figures for a homogeneous fluid mass, endowed with rotational motion, is a difficult problem, which can only be completely resolved when this figure is assumed to be little different from that of a sphere. In this case, there is only one equilibrium figure, which is that of an ellipsoid of revolution flattened at the poles.
To demonstrate this important proposition, Laplace used two methods found in the third book of 'Celestial Mechanics'. The first is based on a series development, which he introduced into analysis, and which recurs repeatedly in the problem of the attraction of spheroids, in that of tides, and in the theory of heat. The illustrious geometer admits the possibility of representing, by this type of series, any function of two variables, a theorem that has since been demonstrated a priori by Poisson.
For fear that this assumption might cast doubt on the results of his analysis, Laplace believed it necessary to demonstrate the proposition in question, independently of the use of series. This second demonstration is incomplete, as noted by M Liouville, who provided a rigorous one. Poisson provided another but this one is still inexact, as we will see.
We will assume here that, in addition to the mutual attraction of its molecules, the fluid mass is subject to the action of a force placed at its centre and reciprocal to the square of the distances; which implicitly includes the case where the fluid mass covers a sphere of density different from its own.
There had been a total eclipse of the sun on Friday 8 July 1842 with the path of totality passing over Milan, Turin, Marseille, Montpellier, Zaragoza and Madrid. Roche had observed the eclipse and published a report of his observations including measurements of red protuberances surrounding the sun. François Arago was very impressed with Roche's report and quoting from it in glowing terms in his own report. Arago offered Roche a place as a free student at the Paris Observatory and, after completing his doctorate in Montpellier in 1844, Roche went to Paris. At the Paris Observatory Roche studied practical astronomy directed by Hervé Auguste Étienne Albans Faye (1814-1902). Faye had studied at the École Polytechnique, leaving in 1834 before completing his course to accept François Arago's offer of position at the Paris Observatory. On 22 November 1843 he had discovered a periodic comet with an orbital period of about 7.5 years, now named 4P/Faye. It brought him international fame and he was awarded the Lalande Prize in 1844 and elected to the French Academy of Sciences in the same year. As well working at the Observatory, Roche attended lectures by Cauchy, Le Verrier, Delaunay, Liouville and Sturm at either the Sorbonne or at the Collège de France.
Towards the end of 1847 Roche returned to Montpellier where he married Marie Ursule Amélie Rigal on 17 November 1847. Marie Rigal (1828-1847) had been born in Montpellier on 29 May 1828 to François Roch Rigal and Caroline Virginie Blanchy. Tragically, Marie Rigal died on 23 November 1847, six days after their marriage, having contracted pneumonia during the wedding festivities. Joseph Boussinesq writes [2]:-
... from then on, the feelings of the most tender affection for a mother, a father and a brother worthy of him were alone to divert the solitude of his heart. It was, I believe, from that day that he ceased to be able to laugh, while retaining the habit of that amiable smile, an expression of his somewhat melancholy goodness, which all his pupils knew.
In 1849 Roche was appointed to the position of chargé de cours at the University of Montpellier and, three years later, in 1852 he was appointed professor of mathematics. In 1848 Roche published his first four papers on astronomy, all in the Mémoires de l'Académie des sciences et lettres de Montpellier. These are: Observation de l'éclipse de soleil du 9 octobre 1847 Ⓣ; Mémoire sur la loi de la densité à l'intérieur de la terre Ⓣ; Mémoire sur la figure de la terre Ⓣ; and Calcul de l'inégalité parallactique du mouvement de la lune Ⓣ.
Much of Roche's work on the solar system is brought together in [16]. He gives the following introduction:-
My studies on the shape of celestial bodies and the arrangement of the level layers in the atmospheres surrounding them have led me to some results applicable to the Sun, its atmosphere, and the progressive condensation by which, as we know, the various planets were formed. I propose to bring together here the consequences of my previous work relating to these questions, and to show how they confirm, clarify, or modify Laplace's cosmogonic theory.
Various problems concerning the solar system will be addressed in this Memoir; but, given the difficulty of the subject, the reader will not be surprised to find, on many points, only mere overviews.
Roche is remembered today largely through Roche lobes and the Roche limit. Roche lobes are equipotential surfaces round a star in a binary system in which material is gravitationally bound to the star. The Roche limit is the distance from a planet at which a moon will be torn into small pieces to form a ring round the planet. Martin Solc write about Roche lobes in [17]:-
Roche devoted himself to topics that lay generally outside of mainstream astronomical research in his time. He studied the equilibrium figure of a rotating fluid body that was subjected to an external gravitational force caused by another body. This condition is extremely important for determining the equipotential surfaces around a pair of bodies like a binary star. Where one (or both) of the components assumes a tear-drop shape, the space(s) so filled is called the Roche lobe.
Iwan P Williams writes about the Roche limit [20]:-
Roche ([12], [13], [14]) had shown some interest in the problems associated with the deformation and fission of rotating fluids, but the work which has become associated with his name as the Roche limit was concerned with the formation of Saturn's rings through mass loss from a hypothetical satellite ([15], [16]). The satellite is taken to be small in size, not deforming Saturn and not in contact in contrast to the assumed situation in the Earth-Moon problem. The gravitational field of both Saturn and the satellite are taken to be that of point masses and Roche consider the loss of a particle from the surface of the satellite at the point nearest Saturn. The satellite is also effectively assumed to be face-on to Saturn, though Roche actually assumed nothing of the satellite, only that the third body that was to be lost stayed on the line joining Saturn and the satellite until lost. ... The Roche limit actually places a limit for the closest distance that a secondary can approach a primary and remain stable under a very idealised set of conditions. In particular the secondary is assumed to move on a circular orbit and maintain the face-on configuration. In reality virtually no secondary moves on a circular orbit and the face-on configuration is far from common.
In [5] Zdenĕk Kopal put Roche's work into context:-
Long before the [Roche problems] emerged to become almost a byword in double-star astronomy in the second half of the present century, astronomers were well aware of their existence which can be traced back - and hence its name - to the French mathematician Édouard Albert Roche (1820-1883). Their roots, to be sure, go much further back in the history of our subject; for - through their connection with the energy integral of the problem of three bodies - many of their properties were known to the German mathematician C G J Jacobi (1804-1851) with whose name they are still sometimes associated. In reality, however, its properties go back to the 18th century to the work of J L Lagrange (1736-1813) and, in fact, to Leonard Euler (1707-1789) - and thus to the early applications of the infinitesimal calculus to dynamical astronomy in the days of Isaac Newton (1642-1727). Yet all these grand men of our science were concerned with certain problems ... solely from the viewpoint of particle mechanics (i.e., the motion of individual particles in the course of time); their relevance to the problems of double-star astronomy was glossed over mainly on account of the fact that no binary stars (or, at least, close binaries) were known to exist in the sky at that time. However, a study of the particular case of equipotential surfaces associated with gravitational dipoles (to which the energy associated with close gravitational dipoles - and to which the energy integral reduces to surfaces of zero velocity (or, more precisely, to surfaces over which the squares of the velocity components are small enough to be ignorable) - has remained the historical task of E A Roche; and it is, therefore, eminently appropriate that these be permanently associated with his name.
Although Roche's work is seen today as being of great importance, it was largely ignored during his lifetime. Kopal suggests that the fact that Roche worked in Montpellier, away from the main areas of astronomical research, might have proved positive for science but negative for his own reputation. Perhaps, Kopal writes, his innovative ideas would have been rubbished by the leading astronomers if he had worked in Paris. The fact that his reputation was poor is illustrated by his failure to be elected to the Academy of Sciences in Paris in 1883. He had been made a corresponding member in December 1873 but when Joseph Liouville died in September 1882, a vacancy occurred in the Astronomical Section of the Academy. Félix Tisserand proposed Roche to fill the vacancy and an election was held on 16 April 1883. Out of 56 votes cast, only one was cast for Roche - this must have been Tisserand's vote.
You can read the report that Tisserand wrote to support his proposal for Roche to fill the vacancy at THIS LINK.
Kopal writes [5]:-
... the rest of the academicians (trying no doubt to avoid the injustice of electing him as one of their equals) voted for others whose names are all forgotten, and their work as dead as mutton. ... Perhaps the main cause of delay to recognise the fundamental nature of Roche's contributions to modern astrophysics was the extent of the ignorance of his age of the internal structure of the stars; for even by the time when Roche died, scholars of the calibre of Henri Poincaré did not find it unreasonable to regard the stars as homogeneous (and sometimes incompressible!) self-gravitating globes for the sake of mathematical simplifications permissible on such a basis. That the actual structure of the stars must be very far from such a model did not begin to transpire until the beginning of the 20th century ...
Although Roche was aware that his name had been put forward for election to the Astronomical Section of the Academy of Sciences, it is almost certain that he would not have known the results of the election since he died of a chest infection only two days after the vote took place.
His Christian faith supported him in his final illness [2]:-
Death did not surprise him. For a long time he had found, in the exercise of the Christian virtues and in the religious practices of a simple faith, all the consolations attached to the hope of a better life and of a more complete light than that which both rejoices and disturbs our wavering reason here below. There he drew the strength to endure with resignation the sufferings of the obstinate cough which was gradually exhausting him. Provided with the last rites of the Church, he saw without faltering the approach of his supreme hour.
We mentioned Édouard Roche's brother Arthur Roche above and promised to give some more information. Arthur Roche also became a mathematician and worked for most of his career as a professor of mathematics at the Montpellier Lycée. Joseph Boussinesq was a pupil at the Montpellier Lycée and writes that Arthur Roche [2]:-
... had, in October and November 1859, completed my preparation for the baccalaureate in science with a few lessons.
Boussinesq ends the article [2] with the following comment:-
May the expression of the unanimous regrets [offered by Roche's colleagues on his death] soften the pain of his brother, to whom you will allow me to offer, in closing, these few pages, because, an excellent professor himself, although in a more modest sphere, he has also acquired, in this capacity, the right to my gratitude.
There is, however, much confusion regarding Arthur Roche. Both the obituaries [8] and [9] are for Arthur Roche and correctly say he taught at Montpellier Lycée. They give, however, Édouard Roche's scientific achievements and are written shortly after Édouard Roche died and 27 years before Arthur Roche died! Clearly both obituaries have confused the two brothers. Certainly [9] claims to take its information from [19] and we note that in [19] Édouard Roche is only referred to as "M Roche".
Finally let us comment on Roche as a teacher by quoting what Boussinesq wrote about taking courses by Roche at the Faculty of Sciences in Montpellier [2]:-
As a student of the Faculty of Sciences of Montpellier, I had the happy experience of following, in 1860 and 1861, Roche's courses in Infinitesimal Analysis and Mechanics, whose listeners unanimously appreciated his clarity and communicative enthusiasm. I was able above all to appreciate, on various occasions, the excellence of his kindness. I find it impossible to forget, for example, the kindness with which he welcomed me and encouraged my first efforts, when, still having only a slight tinge of special Mathematics, I was introduced to him by his younger brother, M Arthur Roche and I expressed to him the desire to devote my life to the study of science.
In 2006 a crater on the far side of the moon was named for Roche. He also has a crater on the Martian moon Phobos named after him.
正文里的方括号编号指向这里,悬停即可直接看到条目。书目保留原文——译了书名反而查不到文献。
原站列出的延伸阅读与外部数据库,照原样保留,目标多为英文页面。
原站的交叉引用。指向本站已镜像专题的留在站内,其余仍指回原站。