数学家传记
阿里·卡什吉是一位伊斯兰天文学家和数学家,出生于现在的乌兹别克斯坦,曾在撒马尔罕和君士坦丁堡的天文台工作,其成果影响了尼古拉·哥白尼提出日心体系。
阿里·卡什吉是皇家猎鹰人的儿子,这位猎鹰人训练猎鹰等鸟类捕捉猎物。让我们首先解释一下,“卡什吉”基本上是一个绰号,意为“猎鹰人卡什吉”,卡什吉这个名字被赋予本传记主人公的父亲。尽管他的名字是Ala al-Din 卡什吉 ibn Muhammed,但他总是被称为卡什吉。
卡什吉出生的城市撒马尔罕于1370年被帖木儿征服,并成为帖木儿帝国的首都。帖木儿是艺术的赞助人,在他的统治下,撒马尔罕成为文化中心。帖木儿于1405年去世,他的儿子沙哈鲁像他的父亲一样是艺术和科学的伟大赞助人,将帖木儿帝国的首都迁至赫拉特。沙哈鲁的儿子乌鲁伯格,帖木儿的孙子,于1409年成为撒马尔罕的统治者。卡什吉的父亲成为乌鲁伯格的猎鹰人,卡什吉在乌鲁伯格周围的文化氛围中长大,尤其是数学和天文学氛围,而乌鲁伯格本人就是一位杰出的数学家和天文学家。乌鲁伯格于1417年至1420年间在撒马尔罕的雷吉斯坦广场建造了一所伊斯兰学校,这是一所研究和教学机构。大约六十位一流学者被乌鲁伯格邀请到这所伊斯兰学校,其中主要教师是Qadi Zada al-Rumi,主要研究者是卡西。
1410年,当46岁的Qadi Zada在撒马尔罕见到乌鲁伯格时,乌鲁伯格只有17岁。乌鲁伯格对科学和文化的兴趣远大于政治或军事征服,但他仍然是整个帝国的副统治者,特别是Mawaraunnahr地区的唯一统治者。Qadi Zada成为乌鲁伯格的伊斯兰学校的主要教师,并在那里度过了余生。他成为卡什吉的老师之一,同样在该伊斯兰学校任教的乌鲁伯格也成为另一位老师。卡什吉还由卡西教授,后者是由乌鲁伯格邀请到该伊斯兰学校的。毫无疑问,卡西是撒马尔罕的主要天文学家和数学家,同一世纪后期的一位历史学家称他为第二个克劳狄乌斯·托勒密。F Jamil Ragep写道[11]:-
撒马尔罕学派似乎强调的一件事是数学科学的重要性。例如,Qadi Zada al-Rumi的传记记载突出了他与老师al-Sayyid al-Sharlf al-Jurjani的困难,后者认为他的学生对数学过于感兴趣而牺牲了哲学。卡西也因拥抱数学科学而闻名,正如我们从给他父亲的信中看到的那样,而乌鲁伯格像许多蒙古/突厥统治者一样,倾向于支持数学科学;此外,他本人也精通这些。年轻的卡什吉就是在这样的氛围中长大的,这似乎对他的知识观产生了深远的影响。
在撒马尔罕学习之后,卡什吉前往波斯的克尔曼(今属伊朗),在那里他对阿曼海的风暴进行了一些研究,并就此主题写了一部著作。继续前行,他于1423年左右到达赫拉特(今属阿富汗)。赫拉特在乌鲁伯格父亲的统治下,与撒马尔罕一样,是一个学术中心,有许多杰出的艺术家、数学家和天文学家。在那里,卡什吉教授天文学,写了一部关于月亮的著作(Explanations on the Periods of the Moon)和另一部关于数学的著作。随后他回到撒马尔罕,将Explanations on the Periods of the Moon呈献给乌鲁伯格。据称乌鲁伯格觉得这部著作如此引人入胜,以至于他站着读完了整部手稿。他确实对卡什吉的工作印象深刻,并任命他为撒马尔罕天文台的天文学家,这是一座当时即将完工的庞大天文台。
撒马尔罕天文台成为当时世界领先的天文台。乌鲁伯格向天文台任命了约六十名天文学家,包括卡什吉、Qadi Zada al-Rumi和卡西。直到约150年后第谷·布拉赫在乌拉尼堡建立他的天文台,世界才有了比撒马尔罕天文台更令人印象深刻的天文台。天文台是一座三层圆柱形建筑,覆盖着釉面砖,设计用于容纳三台巨大的天文仪器。主要仪器的大部分至今尚存,现在被称为法赫里六分仪[15]:-
所谓的“六分仪”显然会远远高出地面……并且很可能更接近于一个象限仪。……该仪器“是迄今为止建造的最大的子午仪器。”弯曲测量轨道的碎片留存下来,上面有约20度的标记;这大约是观测可能达到的最高点。这个“六分仪”会被用来测量主要天体的仰角,尤其是在冬至和夏至时。来自给定天体的光通过一个受控开口,照射在弯曲轨道上,轨道上非常精确地标有度和分。“它可以达到几角秒的分辨率——大约为一度的六百分之一……。目前尚不清楚除了太阳和月亮之外,是否还能以这种方式测量其他天体,因为例如行星不会投射足够的光。天文台配备了各种其他仪器,这些仪器可能构成了其科学测量的最大部分。
卡什吉在撒马尔罕天文台工作到1449年,在内战之后,乌鲁伯格被暗杀。乌鲁伯格的政治才能不及他的数学才能,在他父亲于1447年去世后,尽管是独子,他也无法保住权力。他最终在撒马尔罕被他自己的儿子Abd al-Latif煽动处死。撒马尔罕天文台在乌鲁伯格被暗杀后不久便不复存在,建筑被毁,物品被盗,天文学家被驱逐。卡什吉离开撒马尔罕,前往赫拉特,那是他在受雇于撒马尔罕天文台之前工作过的地方。他写了一些著作,呈献给帖木儿苏丹Abu Said。然而在1469年,Abu Said被Uzun Hasan击败,卡什吉迁往大不里士,即阿塞拜疆黑羊王朝国家的首都。在那里他会见了黑羊王朝的统治者Uzun Hasan,后者要求卡什吉前往君士坦丁堡,作为他与Mehmed II之间的亲善大使,Mehmed II于1451年攻占了君士坦丁堡。Mehmed II欢迎了卡什吉,他于1470年抵达君士坦丁堡,并为他提供了一个在君士坦丁堡的职位,即在Madrasa担任教师。
君士坦丁堡的职位对卡什吉来说看起来非常有吸引力,但他已向Uzun Hasan承诺,他将履行亲善大使的职责,并返回大不里士报告他的使命。他向Mehmed II[7]解释道:-
如果您允许,我想回到大不里士。我在这里存在的真正原因是作为白羊王朝统治者苏丹Hasan的亲善使者。在我接受我的苏丹的盛情邀请之前,我必须回去告知派我来这里并信任我的人,我圆满完成了我的职责……
此事得到同意,卡什吉返回大不里士,向乌尊·哈桑报告了他的使命取得成功。随后他准备前往君士坦丁堡[5]:-
……大约1472年,卡什吉库希携家人和学生永久离开,前往君士坦丁堡……当卡什吉及其随行人员接近君士坦丁堡时,苏丹穆罕默德派了一批学者前去迎接。资料记载,在渡过博斯普鲁斯海峡前往君士坦丁堡的途中,众人就海峡潮汐涨落的原因展开了一场讨论。抵达君士坦丁堡后,卡什吉向苏丹呈献了他的数学著作'al-Muhammadiyya fi al-hisab',该书以苏丹之名命名以示敬意。
到君士坦丁堡后,卡什吉在Sahn-i Thaman Madrasa任教。随后他被任命为阿亚索菲亚经学院的负责人,但他在这一职位上的时间很短,因为他在定居君士坦丁堡两年后便突然去世。他被安葬在艾郁普清真寺的墓地。尽管在君士坦丁堡时间短暂,他在那里却极为成功[5]:-
在这段短暂的时期内,卡什吉教育和影响了大量学生,这些学生连同他的著作,对后世产生了巨大影响。
现在让我们提及卡什吉在撒马尔罕天文台和君士坦丁堡经学院工作期间对数学和天文学作出的众多贡献中的一些。我们首先介绍必须被视为他最重要贡献的内容,即这样一种看法:正是卡什吉的成果间接影响了尼古拉·哥白尼,使他得以提出日心说。这一点在[11]中得到了令人信服的论证,如今已被广泛接受。我们从[11]的导言中摘录几段,以说明卡什吉如何在日心革命中可能发挥了关键作用:-
1973年,Noel Swerdlow对尼古拉·哥白尼如何得出日心说提出了一种新的、意义重大的重构。这一重构基于若干经过重新解读的信息,最重要的是乌普萨拉大学一份手稿中所包含的一组尼古拉·哥白尼手写的笔记。这些笔记提供了令人信服的证据,表明尼古拉·哥白尼将克劳狄乌斯·托勒密的行星本轮模型转变成了偏心模型,以此作为发展以太阳为中心的天文学的第一步。但这种转变依赖于一个一般性命题,即人们确实可以把所有本轮模型都转换为偏心模型。奇怪的是,克劳狄乌斯·托勒密否认这一点,在《天文学大成》第十二卷中声称这仅对外行星(火星、木星和土星)成立,而对内行星(水星和金星)不成立。……
……似乎直到15世纪才有人认识到这一点。Swerdlow找到了他认为尼古拉·哥白尼开始其转换所需的命题的来源,即约翰·缪勒的《天文学大成概要》第十二卷第一和第二章。在第二章中,约翰·缪勒给出了内行星关键理论的简要概述和证明,这将允许尼古拉·哥白尼将所有行星从本轮模型转换为偏心模型。尽管尼古拉·哥白尼在引用中很节省,并且没有在任何地方为这些命题引用约翰·缪勒,但他对《概要》的使用有充分记录,而且似乎没有其他欧洲来源他可以依赖。
无论它们后来被如何使用,约翰·缪勒自己在第十二卷开头包含这些命题的动机仍不清楚。……关于约翰·缪勒的兴趣特别奇怪的是,它显然如此前所未有。无论是在欧洲还是在伊斯兰世界,克劳狄乌斯·托勒密提到的这种偏心替代方案似乎都没有引起太多兴趣。而在被伟大的权威本人拒绝后,将这种替代方案扩展到较低行星的动机更加令人费解。最后,约翰·缪勒呈现这两个命题的方式也很奇怪。他自己没有给出动机——他只是呈现它们。没有提到克劳狄乌斯·托勒密,没有声明克劳狄乌斯·托勒密错了,没有解释为什么克劳狄乌斯·托勒密犯了他的错误,没有声称功劳。
一种可能性是约翰·缪勒没有声称功劳,因为他实际上不是命题的原创者。事实上,根据后续提供的证据,似乎约翰·缪勒的一位年长的同时代人名叫卡什吉很可能发现了这个关键命题,而约翰·缪勒要么在意大利时,要么通过Cardinal Bessarion的中介得知了它,后者最初建议约翰·缪勒和他的合作者格奥尔格·冯·波伊尔巴赫撰写《概要》。
本刊的大多数读者会熟悉约翰·缪勒和格奥尔格·冯·波伊尔巴赫,甚至可能还知道贝萨里翁,但卡什吉很可能是一个不为人知的人物。这令人遗憾,因为至少在我看来,他是十五世纪天文学的主要人物之一。
卡什吉包含这些重要命题的著作是Treatise on the Eccentric Model Being Possible for the Two Lower Planets Just as for the Others。文章[11]包含卡什吉论文的英译,而学位论文[8]则包含另一份带注释的英译。
我们现在必须考察为什么卡什吉准备反驳克劳狄乌斯·托勒密。他拒绝了亚里士多德的科学哲学进路,并提出了自己关于[5]的哲学原则:-
... 存在、存在物、自然、知识和语言的概念。至于数学科学,卡什吉总体上试图将它们从赫尔墨斯-毕达哥拉斯神秘主义中解放出来,并为天文学和光学提供一种替代亚里士多德物理学的依据。
正是这种贯穿他全部工作的哲学,使他能够提出克劳狄乌斯·托勒密是错误的,并且他可以考虑地球运动的可能性,特别是地球自转。这也鼓励他将数学视为理解物理世界的工具,而不是一门本身就有趣的抽象学科。正如Mustapha Kara-卡什吉在[8]中所写,卡什吉认为:-
... 数学实体并非从感官材料中抽象出来,而是通过人类活动如计数、排序、比较等获得的。
尽管我们上面所描述的可能是卡什吉最重要的贡献,但我们注意到他实际上是一位多产的作者,兴趣广泛。今天至少存有他著作的270份手稿副本,涵盖43个不同标题的作品。其中有13部关于数学和天文学的不同作品,7部关于神学和法学的作品,以及24部关于文学主题尤其是语法和语言学的作品。在最近发现他对尼古拉·哥白尼的间接影响之前,他最重要的著作被认为是一部关于伊斯兰哲学的重要作品,实际上是对纳西尔丁·图西(1201-1274)一部作品的评注。卡什吉的Tract on Arithmetic及其Tract on Astronomy的拉丁文译本由John Greaves完成,并于1650年出版。Mustapha Kara-卡什吉在[8]中给出了卡什吉以下两部作品的带注释英译本:Treatise on the Eccentric Model Being Possible for the Two Lower Planets;以及Treatise Regarding the Solution to the Equant Problem。
最后,我们注意到他将君士坦丁堡的经度计算为41°14',接近现代值41°01'。他在协助编纂乌鲁伯格的星表Zij-i Sultani方面是一位主要人物。这是当时最精确的星表,直到150年后才被第谷·布拉赫的工作超越。然而,关于卡什吉对星表贡献的程度存在一些疑问,因为他出版了Sharh-i Zij Ulugh Beg,这是对乌鲁伯格的 Zij-i Sultani的评注,其中卡什吉对其提出了批评并指出了一些错误。
让我们以[8]中的以下引文作为结束:-
卡什吉的观点在他去世后数百年间一直受到争论,他对奥斯曼-土耳其思想和科学探究产生了深远影响,特别是通过宗教学校及其课程。他的影响还扩展到中亚和伊朗,并且有人论证说,他很可能对早期现代欧洲科学产生了直接或间接的影响,他的思想与早期现代欧洲科学有着惊人的相似之处。
Ali Qushji was the son of the royal falconer who trained birds such as falcons to catch pray. Let us begin by explaining that 'Ali Qushji' is basically a nickname meaning 'Ali the Falconer', the name Qushji having been given to the father of the subject of this biography. Although his name was Ala al-Din Ali ibn Muhammed, he is always known as Ali Qushji.
Samarkand, the city where Ali Qushji was born, had been conquered by Tamerlane in 1370 and it became the capital of the Timurid Empire. Tamerlane was a patron of the arts and under his rule Samarkand became a centre for culture. Tamerlane died in 1405 and his son Shah Rukh, like his father a great patron of the arts and sciences, moved the capital of the Timurid Empire to Herat. Shah Rukh's son Ulugh Beg, a grandson of Tamerlane, became the ruler of Samarkand in 1409. Ali Qushji's father became Ulugh Beg's falconer and Ali Qushji grew up in the atmosphere of culture, particularly mathematics and astronomy, around Ulugh Beg who was himself an outstanding mathematician and astronomer. Ulugh Beg built a Madrasa, a research and teaching institute, on Registan Square in Samarkand between 1417 and 1420. Around sixty leading scholars were invited to the Madrasa by Ulugh Beg where the leading teacher was Qadi Zada al-Rumi and leading researcher was Jamshid al-Kashi.
Ulugh Beg was only 17 years old when Qadi Zada, who was 46 years old, met him at Samarkand in 1410. Ulugh Beg was far more interested in science and culture than in politics or military conquest but he was, nevertheless, deputy ruler of the whole empire and, in particular, sole ruler of the Mawaraunnahr region. Qadi Zada became the leading teacher at Ulugh Beg's Madrasa and he spend the rest of his life working there. He became one of Ali Qushji's teachers and Ulugh Beg, who also taught at the Madrasa, became another. Ali Qushji was also taught by Jamshid al-Kashi who had been invited to the Madrasa by Ulugh Beg. There is little doubt that al-Kashi was the leading astronomer and mathematician at Samarkand and he was called the second Ptolemy by an historian writing later in the same century. F Jamil Ragep writes [11]:-
One thing that seems to have been emphasised in the Samarqand School was the importance of the mathematical sciences. Biographical accounts of Qadi Zada al-Rumi, for example, highlight his difficulties with his teacher al-Sayyid al-Sharlf al-Jurjani, who thought his student overly interested in mathematics at the expense of philosophy. Jamshid al-Kashi is also noted for his embrace of the mathematical sciences, as we can see from his letters to his father, and Ulugh Beg, like a number of Mongol/Turkic rulers, was predisposed to support the mathematical sciences; in addition, he himself became proficient in them. It was in this atmosphere that the young Ali Qushji was raised, and this seems to have had a profound effect upon his intellectual outlook.
After his studies in Samarkand, Ali Qushji went to Kerman in Persia (now in Iran), where he conducted some research on storms in the Oman sea and wrote a work on this topic. Moving on, he reached Herat (now in Afghanistan) around 1423. Herat, under the rule of Ulugh Beg's father, was, like Samarkand, a centre for scholarship with many leading artists, mathematicians and astronomers. There Ali Qushji taught astronomy, wrote a work about the Moon (Explanations on the Periods of the Moon) and another on mathematics. He then returned to Samarkand and presented Explanations on the Periods of the Moon to Ulugh Beg. It is claimed that Ulugh Beg found the work so fascinating that he read the whole manuscript while standing up. He was certainly impressed with Ali Qushji's work and appointed him as an astronomer at the Samarkand Observatory, a vast observatory which was nearing completion at this time.
The Samarkand Observatory became the world-leading observatory of its day. Ulugh Beg appointed around sixty astronomers to the observatory including Ali Qushji, Qadi Zada al-Rumi and Jamshid al-Kashi. It was not until Tycho Brahe set up his observatory at Uraniborg about 150 years later, that the world had a more impressive observatory than that at Samarkand. The Observatory was a three-storey cylindrical building covered with glazed tiles which had been designed to house three enormous astronomical instruments. The main instrument, a large part of which has survived, in now called the Fakhri sextant [15]:-
The so-called "sextant" obviously would have extended well above the ground ... and likely was closer to being a quadrant. ... the instrument "was by far the largest meridian instrument ever built." Fragments of the curved measuring track have survived with markings for around 20 degrees; this is about the highest point that observations likely would have been made. The "sextant" would have been used to measure the angle of elevation of major heavenly bodies, especially at the time of the winter and summer solstices. Light from the given body, passing through a controlled opening, would have shone on the curved track, which is marked very precisely with degrees and minutes. "It could achieve a resolution of several seconds of arc - on the order of a six-hundredth of a degree ... . It is not clear whether more than the sun and moon could have been measured in this fashion, since planets, for example, would not have cast sufficient light. The observatory was equipped with a variety of other instruments, which probably accounted for the largest part of its scientific measurement.
Ali Qushji worked at the Samarkand Observatory until 1449 when, following a civil war, Ulugh Beg was assassinated. Beg's political skills were not up to his mathematical skills and, after his father's death in 1447, he was unable to retain power despite being an only son. He was eventually put to death at Samarkand at the instigation of his own son Abd al-Latif. The Samarkand Observatory did not survive long after Ulugh Beg was assassinated as the building was destroyed, its contents were stolen and the astronomers were driven away. Ali Qushji left Samarkand and went to Herat where he had been working before he was employed at the Samarkand Observatory. He wrote works which he presented to the Timurid Sultan Abu Said. In 1469, however, Abu Said was defeated by Uzun Hasan and Ali Qushji moved to Tabriz, the capital of the Qara Qoyunlu state in Azerbaijan. There he met the ruler of the Qara Qoyunlu state, Uzun Hasan, who asked Ali Qushji to go to Constantinople to act as a good will ambassador between himself and Mehmed II, who had captured Constantinople in 1451. Mehmed II welcomed Ali Qushji, who arrived in Constantinople in 1470, and offered him a position in Constantinople as a teacher at the Madrasa.
The position in Constantinople looked very attractive to Ali Qushji but he had promised Uzun Hasan that he would carry out his duty as a good will ambassador and return to Tabriz to report on his mission. He explained to Mehmed II [7]:-
I would like to go back to Tabriz if you let me. The true reason of my existence here is to be the good-will Messenger of Akkoyunlu Ruler, Sultan Hasan. It is necessary for me before I accept the gracious invitation of my Sultan to turn back and inform the person who sent me here and who trusted me that I carried my duty with a good result ...
This was agreed and Ali Qushji returned to Tabriz and reported the success of his mission to Uzun Hasan. He then made preparations to move to Constantinople [5]:-
... around 1472 Ali Qushi, together with his family and students, left permanently for Constantinople ... When Ali Qushji and his entourage approached Constantinople, Sultan Mehmed sent a group of scholars to welcome them. Sources say that in crossing the Bosporus to Constantinople, a discussion ensued about the causes of its ebb and flow. Upon arrival in Constantinople, Ali Qushji presented his mathematical work 'al-Muhammadiyya fi al-hisab' to the sultan, which was named in his honour.
Once in Constantinople, Ali Qushji taught at the Sahn-i Thaman Madrasa. He was then made head of the Ayasofya Madrasa but his time in that role was short lived since he died suddenly two years after settling in Constantinople. He was buried in the cemetery of the Eyyub mosque. Despite his short time in Constantinople, he was highly successful there [5]:-
In this brief period Ali Qushji educated and influenced a large number of students, who, along with his writings, were to have an enormous impact on future generations.
Let us now mention some of the many contributions to mathematics and astronomy that Ali Qushji made while working at the Samarkand Observatory and at the Constantinople Madrasas. We give information first about what must be considered his most important contribution, namely the belief that it was Ali Qushji's results that, indirectly, influenced Copernicus allowing him to put forward his heliocentric theory. This is argued convincingly in [11] and is now widely accepted. We give a few extracts from the introduction of [11] to explain how Ali Qushji may have had a vital role in the heliocentric revolution:-
In 1973, Noel Swerdlow presented a new and significant reconstruction of how Copernicus arrived at the heliocentric theory. This reconstruction was based upon several bits of newly-interpreted information, most importantly a set of notes in Copernicus's hand contained in an Uppsala University manuscript. These notes provided compelling evidence that Copernicus had transformed Ptolemy's epicyclic models of the planets into eccentric models as a first step in developing a Sun-centred astronomy. But this transformation depended upon a general proposition that one could indeed convert all the epicycle models into eccentric ones. Curiously, Ptolemy denied this, claiming in Book XII of the Almagest that this was possible only for the outer planets (Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn) but not the inner ones (Mercury and Venus). ...
... it would seem that no one else recognised this until the fifteenth century. Swerdlow found what he believed to be the source for the propositions Copernicus needed to begin his conversions, namely Book XII, Chapters I and 2 of Regiomontanus's 'Epitome of the Almagest'. In Chapter 2, Regiomontanus gives a brief sketch and proof of the crucial theory for the inner planets, which would allow Copernicus to convert all the planets from epicyclic to eccentric models. Though Copernicus is sparing in his references and nowhere cites Regiomontanus for these propositions, his use of the 'Epitome' is well-documented, and there would seem to have been no other European source that he could have depended upon.
Whatever subsequent use was made of them, Regiomontanus's own motivation for including these propositions at the beginning of Book XII has remained unclear. ... What is especially odd about Regiomontanus's interest is that it is apparently so unprecedented. Neither in Europe nor in the Islamic world does this eccentric alternative alluded to by Ptolemy seem to have generated much interest. And the motivation to extend this alternative to the lower planets, after being rejected by the great authority himself, is even more puzzling. Finally, there is the odd way in which Regiomontanus presents the two propositions. He himself gives no motivation - he just presents them. There is no mention of Ptolemy, no statement that Ptolemy was wrong, no explanation of why Ptolemy made his mistake, no claim of credit.
One possibility is that Regiomontanus does not claim credit because he was not in fact the originator of the proposition. Indeed, it would seem, based on evidence presented in the sequel, that an older contemporary of Regiomontanus named Ali Qushji may well have been the discoverer of this crucial proposition and that Regiomontanus learned of it either while in Italy or through the intermediation of Cardinal Bessarion , who had originally suggested to Regiomontanus and his collaborator Georg Peurbach that they write the 'Epitome'.
Most readers of this journal will be acquainted with Regiomontanus and Peurbach, and perhaps even Bessarion, but Ali Qushji is most likely an unknown figure. This is regrettable since he is, at least in my opinion, one of the major figures in astronomy of the fifteenth century.
The work by Ali Qushji which contains these vital propositions is Treatise on the Eccentric Model Being Possible for the Two Lower Planets Just as for the Others. The article [11] contains an English translation of Ali Qushji's paper, while the thesis [8] contains another English translation with annotations.
We must now look to see why Ali Qushji is prepared to contradict Ptolemy. He had rejected Aristotle's approach to the philosophy of science and produced his own philosophical principles of the [5]:-
... conception of existence, existents, nature, knowledge, and language. As for the mathematical sciences, Ali Qushji in general tried to free them from Hermetic-Pythagorean mysticism and to provide an alternative to Aristotelian physics as the basis for astronomy and optics.
It was this philosophy, which pervades all his work, which allowed him to suggest that Ptolemy was wrong and he could consider the possibility that the earth moved, in particular that it rotated. It also encouraged him to consider mathematics as a tool in understanding the physical world and not as an abstract subject of interest in its own right. As Mustapha Kara-Ali writes in [8], Ali Qushji thought that:-
... mathematical entities are not abstracted from sensory data, but are rather attained through human activity such as counting, ordering, comparing, etc.
Although what we have described above may be the most important of Ali Qushji's contributions, we note that he was in fact a prolific author with interests in a wide range of topics. Today at least 270 manuscript copies of his writings are extant covering works with 43 distinct titles. There are 13 distinct works on mathematics and astronomy, 7 on theology and jurisprudence, and 24 on literary topics especially grammar and linguistics. Before the recent discovery of his indirect influence on Copernicus, his most important work was considered to be a major work on Islamic philosophy which, in fact, is a commentary on a work by Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (1201-1274). Latin translations of Ali Qushji's Tract on Arithmetic and his Tract on Astronomy were made by John Greaves and published in 1650. Annotated English translations of the following two works by Ali Qushji are given by Mustapha Kara-Ali in [8]: Treatise on the Eccentric Model Being Possible for the Two Lower Planets; and Treatise Regarding the Solution to the Equant Problem.
Finally, we note that he calculated the longitude of Constantinople as 41°14', close to the modern value of 41°01'. He was a major figure in assisting in compiling Ulugh Beg's star catalogue, the Zij-i Sultani. This was the most accurate star catalogue of its time and was only surpassed by the work of Tycho Brahe 150 years later. There is some doubt about the extent of Ali Qushji's contributions to the star catalogue, however, since he published Sharh-i Zij Ulugh Beg which was a commentary on Ulugh Beg's Zij-i Sultani in which Ali Qushji made criticisms of it and pointed out some mistakes.
Let us end with the following quote from [8]:-
Ali Qushji's views were debated for centuries after his death, and he exerted a profound influence on Ottoman-Turkish thought and scientific inquiry, in particular through the madrasa and its curriculum. His influence also extended to Central Asia and Iran, and it has been argued that he may well have had an influence, either directly or indirectly, upon early modern European science, to which his ideas bear a striking resemblance.
正文里的方括号编号指向这里,悬停即可直接看到条目。书目保留原文——译了书名反而查不到文献。
原站列出的延伸阅读与外部数据库,照原样保留,目标多为英文页面。
关于阿里·卡什吉的其它页面:
关于阿里·卡什吉的其它网站:
原站的交叉引用。指向本站已镜像专题的留在站内,其余仍指回原站。