数学家传记
亨利·莫尔是一位英国科学哲学家,他的思想可能影响了艾萨克·牛顿。
亨利·莫尔的父亲是Alexander More,他曾多次担任Grantham市长。Alexander More经济富裕,能够给儿子提供一流的教育。关于他的童年知之甚少,除了莫尔自己在《文集》序言中做的几处评论。他在那里写道,他成长于(见[7]或[2]):-
……父母……是伟大的加尔文主义者(但也是非常虔诚和善良的人)。
他从小就被教导要时刻想着宗教:-
……甚至在我最早的童年时期,内心对神之临在的感受如此强烈,以至于我当时相信,任何行为、言语或思想都无法向他隐藏。
在就读格兰瑟姆免费学校(文法学校)后,莫尔十四岁时被送到伊顿公学。在这里,他改变了宗教观点,摒弃了加尔文主义,该主义将预定论视为形而上学的必然性和信仰的基础。莫尔逐渐相信,通过善行可以获得救赎,这一信念他终生坚守。在此期间,他的父亲将他的教养托付给一位叔父,这位叔父试图阻止年轻的莫尔如此早熟,用鞭打来试图让他回归加尔文主义关于自由意志的观念。鞭打当然没有让莫尔回归加尔文主义,也许效果恰恰相反。
1631年,莫尔进入剑桥大学基督学院。他写下了自己作为本科生的经历(见[7]或[2]):-
[我]完全沉浸在哲学研究中;向自己承诺在其中获得最奇妙的幸福。因此,我极其勤勉地钻研亚里士多德、吉罗拉莫·卡尔达诺、尤利乌斯·斯卡利杰和其他最著名的哲学家。事实是,我在这里那里遇到一些机智、敏锐,有时也扎实的言论:然而大多数在我看来要么虚假,要么不确定,要么如此显而易见和琐碎,以至于我认为自己在阅读这些作者时显然浪费了时间。一言以蔽之,我花在这类研究上的几乎整整四年……最终几乎一无所获,只是纯粹的怀疑论。
莫尔于1636年获得学士学位,并留在剑桥继续学业,1639年被选为基督学院的研究员。他将哲学研究转向柏拉图、柏拉图主义者和新柏拉图主义者,成为剑桥柏拉图主义者的一员。
也许我们应该谈谈为什么莫尔会被收入数学家的档案中。他学识广博,而实验自然哲学的思想因那些后来组成皇家学会的人而备受瞩目。这些实验哲学的思想吸引了莫尔,他也受到了勒内·笛卡儿著作的影响,这些著作[1]:-
……似乎展示了如何将对自然的科学兴趣与维护上帝及人类不朽灵魂之实在性的首要关切结合起来。
然而,当他研究勒内·笛卡儿的机械哲学时,他对其感到不满。莫尔论证说,勒内·笛卡儿的观点必然会将上帝从自然中移除,从而导致无神论。在1648年和1649年间,莫尔与勒内·笛卡儿就机械哲学进行了通信,这些通信最终以The Immortality of the Soule(1659年)出版。
莫尔论证说,物体的运动是该物体固有的属性,运动不可能从一个物体转移到另一个物体。这当然似乎与常识相矛盾,因为如果一个滚动的球撞击一个静止的球,那么那个球就会开始运动。莫尔并不否认这个任何简单实验都能证实的事实,但他声称第二个球的运动来自它自身的内在属性,由第一个球的撞击所唤醒。
……我莫尔倾向于这种观点,即绝对没有运动的转移;而是第二个物体可以说被第一个物体的撞击所唤醒而运动,正如这样或那样的事件唤醒灵魂去反思。并且第二个物体与其说是从第一个物体接收运动,不如说是在第一个物体的命令下自行运动。
当然,莫尔在这里的观点完全是谬误的,但当他攻击勒内·笛卡儿的涡旋理论行星运动时,他的立场就更为坚实了:-
为什么你的漩涡不是柱状或圆柱形,而是椭圆形,因为漩涡轴上的任何一点都好像是一个中心,天体物质从中退去,据我所见,具有完全恒定的冲力?……是谁使所有行星不在一个平面(黄道面)上旋转?……而月球本身,既不在地球赤道面上,也不在与此平行的平面上?
莫尔于1652年出版了Antidote Against Atheisme。在这部著作中,他主张自然哲学的所有领域都需要一种“自然之灵”。特别是,他反对罗伯特·波义耳不久前提出的关于空气的弹性和重量的机械解释,这些解释是由罗伯特·波义耳提出的。莫尔在一封信中写道:-
我并不完全满意他从实验中得出的悖论式推论是真实的。对于这一切,将会有一个自然之灵……
在他的所有论证中,人们不得不说,要么莫尔没有读过伽利略和布莱兹·帕斯卡的著作,要么他未能理解他们的论证。当然,莫尔提出了反对空气的弹性和重量的论证,而这些论证已经被布莱兹·帕斯卡回答过了。然而,莫尔不仅仅使用哲学论证来反对罗伯特·波义耳。他是一位坚定的实验科学家,他进行了一系列流体静力学和气体力学实验,以反驳罗伯特·波义耳的理论。
莫尔可能曾强烈反对罗伯特·波义耳的机械哲学,但他对皇家学会中那些人的实验哲学颇有好感。1662年6月4日,约翰·维尔金斯提名他为皇家学会会士,并于同年9月17日当选。然而,当该学会于1663年5月10日从查理二世那里获得特许状时,莫尔(以及其他几人)被从会士名单中遗漏。1664年5月25日,约翰·维尔金斯再次提名莫尔为会士,一周后的会议上他(第二次)当选。
1670年,莫尔出版了Enchridion Metaphysicum。这部著作重复了莫尔对罗伯特·波义耳的机械哲学以及皇家学会其他几位成员的反对意见。当然,当时科学家们正艰难应对与空间和物质、超距作用和真空有关的深层问题,而莫尔的观点激励了许多科学家澄清自己的想法并改进他们的论证。空间是一个特别困难的概念,而莫尔本质上将其等同于上帝:-
相反,当我明确证明内部空间确实与物质不同时,我得出结论,因此它是一种特定的无形实体或精神,正如毕达哥拉斯学派以前所认为的那样。因此,通过笛卡尔哲学似乎意图将上帝排除在世界之外的那同一扇门,我相反地(并且我相信成功将赐予我)努力将他重新引入。而这个无限且不动的广延似乎不仅是真实的,而且是神圣的。
关于莫尔,我们还应该讨论的另一件事是他与艾萨克·牛顿的关系。艾萨克·牛顿出生在格兰瑟姆附近,并就读于格兰瑟姆的免费学校。事实上,他在格兰瑟姆的克拉克先生家寄宿了七年,克拉克先生是免费学校一位教师的兄弟。莫尔比艾萨克·牛顿大约年长30岁,经常回到他的家乡格兰瑟姆,当他这样做时,他与克拉克两兄弟之一住在一起。因此,当莫尔是剑桥的一位重要人物时,他一定认识了年轻的学生艾萨克·牛顿。我们确实知道,艾萨克·牛顿和莫尔之间一直有联系,直到莫尔大约70岁时。
莫尔的空间观念影响了艾萨克·牛顿吗?无法确切地说,但我们当然可以注意到,艾萨克·牛顿的绝对空间和时间观念对他的物理学至关重要,而这种空间概念与莫尔在反对勒内·笛卡儿的论证中提出的空间概念密切相关。此外,就引力而言,对勒内·笛卡儿来说,物体之间必须通过物质发生相互作用。对艾萨克·牛顿来说,引力是一种通过虚空空间作用的力,尽管他似乎没有像莫尔那样将空间等同于上帝,但空间的精神层面支持了艾萨克·牛顿的引力理论。
莫尔从未在剑桥谋求晋升,拒绝竞选诸如院长之类的职位。他是个谦逊的人,觉得自己不具备担任这类职务所需的才能。他写道(见[7]或[2]):-
我已从高处量到深处;我能做什么,我该做什么,我就去做。
Henry More's father was Alexander More who had been mayor of Grantham on several occasions. Alexander More was financially well off and able to give his son a top class education. Little is known of his childhood except for a few comments More makes himself in the Preface of his Collected Works. There he writes that he was brought up (see [7] or [2]):-
... parents ... who were great Calvinists (but withall very pious and good ones).
He was brought up to be always thinking of religion:-
... even in my earliest childhood, an inward sense of the Divine Presence was so strong upon my mind, that I did then believe, there could be no deed, word, or thought hidden from Him.
After attending Grantham Free School (the Grammar School), More was sent to Eton when he was fourteen years old. Here he came to change his religious views, rejecting Calvinism which had the notion of predestination as a metaphysical necessity and the basis of faith. More came to the belief, which he held strongly throughout his life, that salvation was possible though goodness. During this time his father had put his upbringing in the hands of an uncle who tried to prevent the young More from being so forward by flogging him to try to make him return to the Calvinist ideas about free-will. Flogging certainly did nothing to return More to Calvinism, perhaps it had just the opposite effect.
In 1631 More entered Christ's College Cambridge. He wrote of his experiences as an undergraduate (see [7] or [2]):-
[I plunged] over head and ears in the study of philosophy; promising a most wonderful happiness to myself in it. Aristotle, therefore, Cardan, Julius Scaliger and other philosophers of the greatest note I very diligently pursued. In which the truth is, that I met here and there with some things wittily and acutely and sometimes also solidly spoken: yet the most seemed to me either false or uncertain, or else so obvious and trivial, that I look upon myself as having plainly lost my time in reading such authors. And to speak all in a word, those almost whole four years which I spent on studies of this kind ... ended in nothing, in a manner, but mere scepticism.
More graduated with a B.A. in 1636 and remained at Cambridge to continue his studies being elected a Fellow of Christ's College in 1639. He turned his philosophical studies towards Plato, the Platonists and the Neoplatonists becoming a member of the Cambridge Platonists.
Perhaps we should move towards the reason why More is included in an archive of mathematicians. He was a man of broad learning, and the ideas of experimental natural philosophy were to the fore due to those who would form the Royal Society. These ideas of experimental philosophy attracted More and he also became influenced by the writings of Descartes which [1]:-
... seemed to show how to combine a scientific interest in nature with a primary concern for vindicating the reality of God and immortal human souls.
However, as he studied the mechanical philosophy of Descartes he became unhappy with it. More argued that Descartes' ideas must inevitably remove God from nature and so lead to atheism. During 1648 and 1649 More and Descartes corresponded about the mechanical philosophy and this correspondence was eventually published as The Immortality of the Soule (1659).
More argued that the motion of a body was an inherent property of that body, and that it was impossible for motion to be transferred from one body to another. This, of course, seems to contradict common sense for if a rolling ball strikes a ball which is at rest then the ball starts to move. More does not deny this fact which any simple experiment will verify, but he claimed that the motion of the second ball is from an internal property of its own, awakened by the impact of the first ball.
... I am the more inclined to this opinion, that there is absolutely no transfer of motions; but that a second body is as it were awakened into motion by the impact of the first body, as this or that event awakens the soul to reflection. And that the second body does not so much receive motion from the first, as put itself into motion at the bidding of the first.
Of course More's ideas here are totally fallacious but when he attacks Descartes' vortex theory planetary motion the he is on stronger ground:-
Why are not your vortices in the form of columns or cylinders rather than ellipses, since any point of the axis of a vortex is as it were a centre from which the celestial matter recedes with, as far as I can see, a wholly constant impetus? ... Who causes all the planets not to revolve in one plane (the plane of the ecliptic)? ... And the Moon itself, neither in the plane of the Earth's equator nor in a plane parallel to this?
More published Antidote Against Atheisme in 1652. In this work he argues that all areas of natural philosophy require a "Spirit of Nature". In particular he argued against the mechanical explanations of the spring and weight of the air as Boyle put forwards by Boyle shortly before. More wrote in a letter:-
I be not altogether satisfied that his paradoxical inferences from the experiments are true. There will be a Spirit of Nature for all of this ...
In all his arguments one would have to say that either More had not read the works of Galileo and Pascal, or that he had failed to understand their arguments. Certainly More puts forward arguments against the spring and weight of air which had already been answered by Pascal. More did not just use philosophical arguments against Boyle, however. He was a committed experimental scientist and he undertook a series of hydrostatic and pneumatic experiments to disprove Boyle's theory.
More may have been strongly opposed to Boyle's mechanical philosophy, but he was well disposed towards the experimental philosophy of those in the Royal Society. He was proposed for fellowship of the Royal Society by Wilkins on 4 June 1662 and elected on 17 September of that year. However, when the Society received its Charter from Charles II on 10 May 1663, More (and several others) were omitted from the list of Fellows. On 25 May 1664 Wilkins again proposed More for the fellowship and he was elected (for a second time) at the meeting one week later.
In 1670 More published Enchridion Metaphysicum. This work repeated More's objections to the mechanical philosophy of Boyle and several other members of the Royal Society. Of course there were deep problems which related to space and matter, action at a distance and the vacuum which scientists were struggling with at this time and More's views provided motivation to many scientists to clarify their own ideas and improve their arguments. Space was a particularly difficult concept and More essentially identifies it with God:-
I on the contrary when I have manifestly proved that the internal space is really distinct from matter, I conclude that it is for that reason a certain incorporeal substance or spirit, just as the Pythagoreans formerly thought. And so through that same gate through which the Cartesian philosophy seemed to intend to exclude God from the world, I on the contrary (and I am confident that success will be vouchsafed me) strive to reintroduce Him. And this infinite and immobile extension appears to be not only real but divine.
One other thing about Henry More which we should discuss is his relation to Newton. Newton was born close to Grantham and attended the Free School in Grantham. In fact he had lodgings in Grantham for seven years with a Mr Clark, the brother of a teacher at the Free School. More, who was about 30 years older than Newton, often returned to his home town of Grantham and when he did so he lived with one of the two Clark brothers. Therefore when More was a major figure at Cambridge he must have got to know the young pupil Newton. We certainly know that there was contact between Newton and More up till the time More was around 70 years of age.
Did More's ideas of space influence Newton? It is impossible to say with any certainty, but we can certainly note that Newton's idea of absolute space and time was crucial to his physics and that this notion of space is closely related to that put forward by More in his arguments against Descartes. Also in terms of gravity, for Descartes it was necessary to have an interaction through matter between the bodies. For Newton gravity was a force which acted through empty space and although he does not appear to have identified space with God as More did, nevertheless the spiritual aspect of space supported Newton's gravitational theories.
More never sought advancement within Cambridge, refusing to stand for positions such as Master. He was a modest man who felt that he did not have the necessary talents for such roles. He wrote (see [7] or [2]):-
I have measured myself from the height to the depth; and what I can do, and what I ought to do, and I do it.
正文里的方括号编号指向这里,悬停即可直接看到条目。书目保留原文——译了书名反而查不到文献。
原站列出的延伸阅读与外部数据库,照原样保留,目标多为英文页面。
关于亨利·莫尔的其它网站: