数学家传记
伊姆雷·拉卡托斯是一位匈牙利数学哲学家和科学哲学家,在1953年俄罗斯入侵匈牙利后移居英国。
伊姆雷·拉卡托斯出生时取名为Imre Lipschitz,出生在一个犹太家庭,正如他的名字清楚表明的那样。他的一生将被纳粹上台和第二次世界大战造成的混乱所主导,战争爆发时Imre正在学校的最后几年。
对匈牙利来说,这是一个艰难的时期,国家不确定是站在希特勒一边还是站在盟国一边,但在许多方面匈牙利几乎没有选择。希特勒决定,他不能让自己至关重要的通讯线路任由一个未表态的匈牙利政权摆布。1944年3月,希特勒给匈牙利两个选择:要么与德国合作,要么德国军队占领该国。匈牙利选择了合作,并任命了一个与希特勒合作的政府。德国人为所欲为,镇压反对者,逮捕任何公开反对他们的人。犹太人被迫佩戴黄星,他们的财产被没收。
拉卡托斯在德布勒森大学度过了战争岁月,并于1944年毕业,获得数学、物理学和哲学学位。为了躲避纳粹对犹太人的迫害,他将自己的名字改为Imre Molnár,他幸存了下来,而其他犹太裔的人则被驱逐到德国集中营的毒气室。战争期间,匈牙利75万犹太人中超过55万人被纳粹杀害,其中包括拉卡托斯的母亲和祖母,她们都死于奥斯维辛。
战争结束后,此时已是活跃共产主义者的拉卡托斯意识到,既然他的名字现在是拉卡托斯 Molnár,穿着印有“I. L.”的旧衬衫会有困难。匈牙利陷入严重的财政困境,弄到一批新衬衫比改名字还难,所以他改了名字,不是改回犹太名字鲁道夫·利普希茨,而是按照他的政治观点,改成了匈牙利工人阶级的名字拉卡托斯。他可能是从匈牙利将军Géza 拉卡托斯那里借用了这个名字,后者曾短暂领导过一个寻求和平的匈牙利政府,之后德国人安插了自己的人掌权。至少拉卡托斯现在又可以穿他的“I. L.”衬衫了!
1947年,拉卡托斯在匈牙利教育部获得了一个职位。然而,他不善于不加质疑地接受俄罗斯当局的命令,拉卡托斯很快发现他的观点使他陷入了政治麻烦。1950年,他被逮捕并在斯大林主义监狱中服刑三年[1]:-
他后来常说,有两个因素帮助他活了下来:他坚定不移的共产主义信仰,以及他不捏造证据的决心。(他还说过,而且人们也相信这一点:审讯的压力对他——对他的一名审讯者来说——实在太大了!)
1953年,也就是斯大林去世的那一年,他获释后,雷尼·奥尔弗雷德帮助拉卡托斯找到了工作。拉卡托斯靠把数学书翻译成匈牙利语谋生。他当时翻译的书中包括乔治·波利亚的书How to Solve it。
1956年,匈牙利爆发了反对控制该国的俄罗斯政权的革命。1956年11月1日,匈牙利退出华沙条约组织,并请求联合国承认其为联合国保护下的中立国。两天后,俄罗斯坦克就位,一个傀儡政府被建立起来。许多人被送往苏联,其中许多人再也没有回来。约20万难民逃往西方,其中很大一部分是匈牙利受过教育的阶层。拉卡托斯意识到自己即将被捕,便逃往维也纳。
拉卡托斯辗转来到英国,开始在剑桥大学攻读哲学博士学位。他的工作受到波普尔和乔治·波利亚的影响,后来他写出了1961年提交给剑桥的博士论文Essays in the Logic of Mathematical Discovery。在乔治·波利亚的建议下,他的论文以莱昂哈德·欧拉-勒内·笛卡儿公式的历史为主题。1960年,拉卡托斯被任命到伦敦经济学院,他在那里任教14年,直至去世。他的讲课情况在[1]中有描述:-
他讲课时,教室里总是挤满了人,气氛热烈,不时爆发出一阵大笑。
在[1]中,Ernest Gellner再次写道:-
他讲授的是一个艰深、抽象、充满技术细节的课题——数学与科学的哲学和歷史;但他讲得通俗易懂、引人入胜、富有戏剧性,尤其是对非专业人士也明显妙趣横生。
拉卡托斯于1963-64年在British Journal for Philosophy of Science上分四部分发表Proofs and Refutations。这部作品基于他的学位论文,以一位教师和一群学生之间讨论的形式写成。Worrall [17]这样描述这篇论文:-
……除了具有重大的哲学和历史价值外,还以单行本形式大量流传。
拉卡托斯生前拒绝将此作品作为书出版,因为他打算改进它。然而,1976年,即他去世两年后,这部作品确实以书的形式问世:J Worrall and E G Zahar (eds.),I Lakatos : Proofs and Refutations : The Logic of Mathematical Discovery 。
Worrall [17]这样描述这部作品:-
《证明与反驳》的论点是,数学的发展并不像传统数学哲学告诉我们的那样,在于永恒真理的稳步积累。根据拉卡托斯,数学以一种更为戏剧性和激动人心的方式发展——通过猜想的过程,接着是试图“证明”猜想(即将其归约为其他猜想),然后是通过试图对猜想的定理和证明中的各个步骤提出反例来进行批评。
Hersh [9]说Proofs and Refutations是:-
……一部压倒性的著作。其论辩的辉煌、论证的复杂与自觉的精妙、历史学识的厚重分量,效果是令读者目眩。
拉卡托斯在转向更广泛地撰写科学哲学之前,写了许多数学哲学方面的论文。然而,如同他的学位论文一样,他常常用历史案例研究来阐明自己的论点。我[EFR]强烈推荐拉卡托斯发表在The Mathematical Intelligencer(3)(1978), 151-161上的文章。这篇文章,Cauchy and the Continuum : The Significance of 非标准分析 for the History and Philosophy of Mathematics,是我读过的最令人愉快的文章之一。Hersh[9]解释了拉卡托斯在这篇文章中所使用的历史研究方法的要点:-
要点不仅仅在于重新思考奥古斯丁·路易·柯西的推理,不仅仅在于利用亚伯拉罕·鲁滨逊的非标准分析所提供的数学洞见来重新评价我们对整个微积分历史和无穷小概念的态度。要点在于揭示数学增长与变化作为一个历史过程的内在运作机制,作为一个有其自身规律和自身“逻辑”的过程,这一过程最好在其理性重构中被理解,而实际的历史或许只是它的拙劣模仿。
作为研究导师,拉卡托斯极为高效[1]:-
他激励一群年轻学者从事原创研究:他常常在出版前与他们一起花数天时间讨论他们的手稿。
拉卡托斯去世时正值他极具创造力之际,有许多计划要发表新作、回应批评者并将他的思想应用于新领域。然而Worrall[17]指出,拉卡托斯最引以为豪的成就是留下了:-
……一个蓬勃发展的研究纲领,由伦敦政治经济学院及其他地方的年轻学者们参与,他们致力于发展并批评他那些富有启发性的思想,并将其应用于新的领域。
他的性格在[1]中被描述为:-
他言辞犀利、观点强硬,有时显得独断专行;但他对每个人都“拉卡托斯”;他欢迎人们对其思想进行深入探究的批评,也欢迎对其著作的批评,而这些著作在最终获准付印之前,他总要花费无尽的心力。
Imre Lakatos was given the name Imre Lipschitz at birth, born into a Jewish family as his name clearly indicated. His life would be dominated by the chaos that resulted from the Nazi rise to power and World War II, the war breaking out when Imre was in his final years at school.
It was a difficult period for Hungary, with the country unsure whether to side with Hitler or with the allies, but in many ways Hungary had few options. Hitler decided that he could not leave his vital communications at the mercy of an uncommitted Hungarian regime. In March 1944 Hitler offered Hungary the choice of either cooperating with Germany or the German armies would occupy the country. Hungary chose cooperation and appointed a government to collaborate with Hitler. The Germans did as they pleased, suppressing opponents and arresting anyone who spoke out against them. Jews were compelled to wear a yellow star and their property was taken away.
Imre had spent the war years at the University of Debrecen and he graduated in 1944 with a degree in mathematics, physics and philosophy. To avoid the Nazi persecution of Jews he changed his name to Imre Molnár, and he survived while others of Jewish descent were deported to the gas chambers of German concentration camps. More than 550,000 of Hungary's 750,000 Jews were killed by the Nazis during the war, including Imre's mother and grandmother who both died in Auschwitz.
After the war ended Imre, who by this time was an active communist, realised that he would have difficulty wearing his old shirts with "I. L." on them when his name was now Imre Molnár. Hungary was in grave financial trouble and getting a new collection of shirts was harder than changing one's name so he changed his name, not back to the Jewish Lipschitz but rather, in keeping with his political views, to the Hungarian working class name of Lakatos. He may have borrowed the name from the Hungarian general Géza Lakatos who headed a peace seeking Hungarian government for a short while before the Germans put their own man in charge. At least Imre Lakatos could now wear his "I. L." shirts again!
In 1947 Imre Lakatos obtained a post in the Hungarian Ministry of Education. However he was not good at taking orders from Russian authorities without questioning them and Lakatos soon found that his views had put him in political trouble. In 1950 he was arrested and served three year in a Stalinist prison [1]:-
He used to say afterwards that two factors helped him to survive: his unwavering communist faith and his resolve not to fabricate evidence. (He also said, and one believes it, that the strain of interrogation proved too much - for one of his interrogators!)
On his release in 1953, the year of Stalin's death, Rényi helped Lakatos find work. Lakatos earned his living translating mathematics books into Hungarian. Among the books that he translated at this time was Pólya's book How to Solve it.
In 1956 there was revolution in Hungary against the Russian regime which controlled the country. On 1 November 1956 Hungary withdrew from the Warsaw Pact and asked the United Nations to recognise it as a neutral state, under the protection of the United Nations. Two days later Russian tanks were in position and a puppet government was set up. Many people were sent to the Soviet Union and many of those never returned. Around 200,000 refugees escaped to the West, a substantial proportion being Hungary's educated classes. Lakatos realised that he was about to be arrested and fled to Vienna.
Eventually Lakatos found his way to England and he began to study at the University of Cambridge for a doctorate in philosophy. His work was influenced by Popper and by Pólya and he went on to write his doctoral thesis Essays in the Logic of Mathematical Discovery submitted to Cambridge in 1961. At Pólya's suggestion his thesis took as its theme the history of the Euler-Descartes formula . In 1960 Lakatos was appointed to the London School of Economics and he taught there for 14 years until his death. His lecturing is described in [1]:-
When he lectured, the room would be crowded, the atmosphere electric, and from time to time there would be a gale of laughter.
Again in [1] Ernest Gellner writes:-
He lectured on a difficult, abstract subject riddled with technicalities, the philosophy and history of mathematics and science; but he did so in a way which made it intelligible, fascinating, dramatic and above all conspicuously amusing even for non-specialists.
Lakatos published Proofs and Refutations in 1963-64 in four parts in the British Journal for Philosophy of Science. This work was based on his doctoral thesis and is written in the form of a discussion between a teacher and a group of students. Worrall [17] describes the paper:-
... as well as having great philosophical and historical value, was circulated in offprint form in enormous numbers.
During his lifetime Lakatos refused to publish the work as a book since he intended to improve it. However, in 1976, two years after his death, the work did appear as a book: J Worrall and E G Zahar (eds.), I Lakatos : Proofs and Refutations : The Logic of Mathematical Discovery .
Worrall [17] describes the work:-
The thesis of 'Proofs and Refutations' is that the development of mathematics does not consist (as conventional philosophy of mathematics tells us it does) in the steady accumulation of eternal truths. Mathematics develops, according to Lakatos, in a much more dramatic and exciting way - by a process of conjecture, followed by attempts to 'prove' the conjecture (i.e. to reduce it to other conjectures) followed by criticism via attempts to produce counter-examples both to the conjectured theorem and to the various steps in the proof.
Hersh [9] says that Proofs and Refutations is:-
... an overwhelming work. The effect of its polemical brilliance, its complexity of argument and self-conscious sophistication, its sheer weight of historical learning, is to dazzle the reader.
Lakatos wrote a number of papers on the philosophy of mathematics before moving on to write more generally on the philosophy of science. However, like his doctoral thesis, he often used historical case studies to illustrate his arguments. I [EFR] would strongly recommend the article in The Mathematical Intelligencer (3) (1978), 151-161 by Lakatos. This article, Cauchy and the Continuum : The Significance of Non-Standard Analysis for the History and Philosophy of Mathematics is one of the most enjoyable that I have read. Hersh [9] explains the point of the approach to history that Lakatos uses in this article:-
The point is not merely to rethink the reasoning of Cauchy, not merely to use the mathematical insight available from Robinson's non-standard analysis to re-evaluate our attitude towards the whole history of the calculus and the notion of the infinitesimal. The point is to lay bare the inner workings of mathematical growth and change as a historical process, as a process with its own laws and its own 'logic', one which is best understood in its rational reconstruction, of which the actual history is perhaps only a parody.
As a research supervisor, Lakatos was extremely effective [1]:-
He inspired a group of young scholars to do original research: he would often spend days with them on their manuscripts before publication.
Lakatos died at a time when he was highly productive with many plans to publish new work, make replies to his critics and apply his ideas to new areas. Worrall [17] however points out that the achievement of which Lakatos would have been most proud was leaving:-
... a thriving research programme manned, at the London School of Economics and elsewhere, by young scholars engaged in developing and criticising his stimulating ideas and applying them to new areas.
His character is described in [1]:-
With his sharp tongue and strong opinions he sometimes seemed authoritarian; but he was "Imre" to everyone; and he invited searching criticism of his ideas, and his writings over which he took endless trouble before they were finally allowed to appear in print.
正文里的方括号编号指向这里,悬停即可直接看到条目。书目保留原文——译了书名反而查不到文献。
原站列出的延伸阅读与外部数据库,照原样保留,目标多为英文页面。
原站的交叉引用。指向本站已镜像专题的留在站内,其余仍指回原站。