数学家传记
乔万尼·巴蒂斯塔·贝内戴蒂是一位意大利数学家,他预见了伽利略关于自由落体的一些工作。
乔万尼·巴蒂斯塔·贝内戴蒂出生于威尼斯一个地位显赫的富裕家庭,并在该城度过了童年和少年时代。他的父亲被卢卡·瓜里科(写于1552年)描述为[1]:-
……一个西班牙人,哲学家和physicus,可能意为“自然研究者”,但也可能意为“医学博士”。
贝内戴蒂由父亲教授哲学、音乐和数学。从七岁起,他似乎没有接受过正规教育,当然也没有上过大学。贝内戴蒂大概在1546至1548年间,跟随Niccolo Fontana(更广为人知的名字是尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚)学习了欧几里得的Elements的前四卷,尽管后来他们似乎闹翻了。我们从以下事实推断出这一点:尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚在其著作中没有提到他曾教过贝内戴蒂,而贝内戴蒂只提到他曾受教于尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚,“以给他应得的认可”:-
尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚只教了我欧几里得的前四卷,其余全部是我自己通过极大的细心和研究学到的。对于愿意学习的人来说,没有什么是困难的。
当然,在贝内戴蒂是尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚学生的时期,尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚卷入了与洛多维科·费拉里的公开挑战,并因此失去了声誉。这必定对他的学生产生了重大影响,因此,在贝内戴蒂后来的著作中,他对尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚的著作持高度批评态度,这并不令人意外。当贝内戴蒂年仅二十二岁时,他写了Resolutio omnium Euclidis problematumaliorumque ad hoc necessario inventorum una tantummodo circini data apertura,该书于1553年在威尼斯出版。在这部著作中,他仅使用固定开度的圆规,讨论了欧几里得的Elements中所有问题的一般解法,以及其他几何问题。具有重要意义的是,仅用固定开度的圆规证明欧几里得某些定理的问题,曾被尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚作为挑战向吉罗拉莫·卡尔达诺和洛多维科·费拉里提出,因此这很可能为贝内戴蒂的研究提供了动力。贝内戴蒂考虑了这个问题:-
使用一副固定开度的圆规,构造一个三边已知的三角形,使得其中两边之和大于第三边。
解决了这个问题后,他用它来求给定圆心和半径的两圆的交点。然后他自豪地宣称:-
尽管许多聪明的古代和现代数学家说这个问题不可能解决,我还是完成了这个构造……我于1552年10月15日发现了它。
洛多维科·费拉里和尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚都产生了关于仅使用固定开度的圆规的结果,但两者都没有产生像贝内戴蒂那样系统或质量的东西。事实上,尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚的最后一部作品是Trattato generale di numeri e misure (1560年),正是关于那个主题——它的质量不如贝内戴蒂的作品,而且有趣的是,甚至没有提到贝内戴蒂或Resolutio。然而,在Resolutio中还有别的东西非常重要,但与作品的主要主题毫无关系。这是一封献给Gabriel de Guzman的献词信,Guzman是一位西班牙多明我会神父,他曾在1552年在威尼斯与Guzman讨论过贝内戴蒂的自由落体理论。Guzman曾建议贝内戴蒂发表关于自由落体速度的数学处理,这封信就是他给Guzman的回答。人们可能会问,为什么他选择把这封无关的信作为Resolutio的献词发表。答案是贝内戴蒂担心如果不尽快印刷出来,他的想法会被窃取,所以他选择了这条途径。我们应该注意到,他的担心是完全有道理的,因为正如我们下面所述,尽管有这些尝试,他的理论还是被窃取了。
贝内戴蒂关于自由落体的这些观点是什么?他提出,由相同材料构成的物体无论重量如何都以相同的速度下落。他用一个论证来证明自己的主张,其中使用了阿基米德关于流体中物体的结果。当然,在当时亚里士多德的观点被毫无疑问地接受,而贝内戴蒂所提出的观点与亚里士多德完全矛盾。正如人们可能预料的那样,读过贝内戴蒂著作的人并不接受他的观点。有些人认为这些观点是愚蠢的,另一些人同意他的发现,但说这些发现必定与亚里士多德一致。贝内戴蒂本人评论说,他在罗马有批评者,他们说亚里士多德总是正确的,所以他的著作必定是错误的。他在他的下一部著作Demonstratio proportionum motuum localium contra Aristotelem et omnes philosophos中回答了批评者,该书于1554年在威尼斯出版。在这部著作中,他重复了关于自由落体的论证,并通过引用亚里士多德著作中与之矛盾的那些段落,清楚地表明他所提出的观点与亚里士多德相矛盾。这部著作的两个版本迅速相继问世,第二版包含了对他的观点的修改。在这个第二版中,他说下落重物的速度会因其表面积而取决于与空气的摩擦,只有在真空中,不同大小的物体才会以相同的速度下落。
1554年,即贝内戴蒂的Demonstratio出版的那一年,他的女儿在都灵出生。没有他婚姻的记录,尽管不应从这一事实中读出任何意义。我们确实知道他在1585年结婚了,但有可能这是第二次婚姻,或者他在此时与第一任妻子和女儿重新团聚。回到1550年代,我们记录贝内戴蒂从1558年到1566年被任命为帕尔马公爵Ottavio Farnese的宫廷数学家。在帕尔马[19]:-
……他履行数学家的职责,担任占星家、日晷的设计者和建造者,以及公国公共工程工程的顾问。
贝内戴蒂相当富有,所以当公爵长期不付他报酬时,他在经济上一点也不担心。所谓长期,我们指的是有一段十个月和另一段二十个月,他没有得到报酬。在帕尔马受雇期间,贝内戴蒂在1559-60年冬天在罗马讲授亚里士多德科学[1]:-
Girolamo Mei在那里听过他的课,称赞他的敏锐、思想的独立、流利和记忆力。
1587年,贝内戴蒂成为公爵数学家和哲学家,受雇于萨伏依公爵Emanuele Filberto,他担任这个职位直到去世。他还已知在搬到都灵后的最初几年在都灵大学任教。都灵大学数学教授Bartolomeo Cristini在1611年写了以下关于贝内戴蒂的内容(例如见[19]):-
[Emanuele Filberto]确实如此热爱这些数学技艺,以至于为了给我们都灵大学带来声望,他从国外邀请了所有这些技艺中最好、最精通的人,并用优厚的薪俸说服了他们。其中我要提到贝内戴蒂,他在数学抽象方面极为精通,并为后世留下了许多优秀著作,包含对自然哲学每一个分支的原创性贡献。
弗朗切斯科·莫罗西尼,威尼斯驻萨伏依宫廷大使,写道(例如见[19]):-
既然数学科学对于打算习武的人来说非常有用且必要,所以殿下乐在其中,他的知识远不止过得去。他意识到,一个人只要继续考察和研究一门科学,就懂得这门科学,因此他每天都听一节关于欧几里得或那些科学另一位作者的课,授课者是威尼斯人贝内戴蒂Battista Benedetti先生,这个人不仅在我看来,而且按照许多专家的判断,目前在这一专业中是最好的,并且深受公爵赏识,因为除了拥有这门最卓越的科学之外,他还是一位如此优秀的教师,以至于他的每个学生都很容易变得胜任并精通它。
贝内戴蒂出版了De gnomonum umbrarumque solarium liber(1574),一本关于日晷的书。他在扉页上写道,这本书“现在首次印刷,以供公众使用和学生方便。”在一封将此书献给Emanuele Filberto的信中,贝内戴蒂写道:-
我们这本关于日晷的小书,尊贵的公爵,是我在过去几年中撰写的,现在终于可以问世了。
在都灵期间,他还设计并建造了日晷和喷泉。接着他出版了De temporum emendatione opinio, Augustae Taurinorum(1578),内容是关于历法修正。次年,他出版了他的Considerutione di Gio. Battista Benedetti Filosofo del Sereniss. S. Duca di Suvoia,在其中他对当时一场关于土和水两种元素相对体积的争论作出了贡献。他的最后一部著作Diversarum Speculationum Mathematicarum et Physicarum Liber Ad Sereniss. Carolum Emunuelem Allobrogum et Subalpinorum ducem invictissimum收录了贝内戴蒂多年来撰写的几篇不同作品。我们将在下面更详细地讨论这里发表的关于透视法和音乐的重要材料。首先我们注意到,Diversarum Speculationum包含对欧几里得第五卷的评注,以及许多几何定理的汇集,包括作给定各边的四边形的外接。在关于几何的一节中,他还处理了球面三角形、圆和圆锥曲线。其中有他对等周图形、正多边形和正多面体贡献的细节。在处理正多边形时,贝内戴蒂证明了阿尔布雷希特·丢勒用固定开度的圆规作正五边形的方法并不精确。
Diversarum Speculationum 中有一节关于力学的部分,其中 贝内戴蒂 再次攻击 亚里士多德 的物理概念,也攻击 尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚 的力学。我们应当注意,在这一节中他声称,如果一个物体从圆周运动中被释放,它将沿一条与原运动圆相切的直线运动。贝内戴蒂 当然应该获得首次发表这一主张的荣誉。他还重复了关于自由落体的论证。他给出的论证是,如果两个重量相等的物体被释放,然后同样的物体用一根线连接后被释放,那么直观上,两种情况下的下落速度会相同。Stillman Drake 在 [1] 中评论道:-
贝内戴蒂 正确地认为,自然的直线运动由于持续受到向下的冲力而速度不断增加,而 伽利略 错误地认为加速度只是自由落体开始时偶然且暂时的效应。
尽管 伽利略 在 De motu 中有这个错误,他后来意识到了自己的错误并在后来的著作中加以纠正。我们绝不能给人这样的印象:贝内戴蒂 的贡献比 伽利略 的更好,因为尽管他在某些点上理解更深,但他并未尝试给出加速度的数学表述,而这是 伽利略 的伟大成就。在 Diversarum Speculationum 中,贝内戴蒂 还考虑了流体静压力和液压提升的想法。他正确地声称风是由于太阳加热物体导致空气密度变化而引起的,这与物体的不透明度有关。他表明他正确地理解了云。
我们曾承诺要回到他对音乐的贡献。尽管这仅在 1585 年出版,但其思想包含在写给 Cipriano da Rore 的两封信中,后者在 1561-62 年担任帕尔马宫廷的唱诗班指挥。贝内戴蒂 一定在这段时间与他进行过讨论,然后在 da Rore 离开帕尔马前往威尼斯后不久的 1563 年写下了这两封信。Stillman Drake 写道 [1]:-
偏离当时流行的和声数字理论,贝内戴蒂 探究了音高、协和与振动速率之间的关系。他将音乐协和的产生归因于空气波的汇合或共同决定。这种由振动弦撞击空气而产生的波,应当要么彼此一致,要么相互打断。如此推进,并断言在相等张力下两根弦的振动频率与弦长成反比,贝内戴蒂 提出了一种通过将给定协和的比例项相乘而获得的一致性指数;通过这种方式,他可以在数学尺度上表达和谐程度。
在 [18] 中,这些音乐贡献用稍微更专业的术语描述如下:-
在约1563年写给作曲家Cipriano de Rore的一封信中,科学家贝内戴蒂提出了一种关于协和音成因的新理论。贝内戴蒂论证说,既然声音由空气波或振动构成,那么在较为协和的音程中,较短而频率较高的波与较长而频率较低的波会以规则的时间间隔重合。另一方面,在较不协和的音程中,重合很少发生,两个音在耳中不会愉快地融合。他指出,例如在纯五度中,两种振动会在较低音的每两个周期和较高音的每三个周期相遇。他接着表明,就重合频率而言,八度内的比例层级将是2:1、3:2、4:3、5:3、5:4、6:5、7:5、8:5,这既挑战了超特定比例(super-particular ratios)的优越性,也挑战了senario的神圣性。从协和到不协和不可能有突然的断裂,而只能是一个音程的连续统,有些更协和,有些较不协和。贝内戴蒂的理论在下一个世纪被Isaac Beeckman和马兰·梅森所采纳,他们寻求勒内·笛卡儿对此的意见。
现在让我们转向贝内戴蒂对透视法的贡献。在[3]中,Elkins写道:-
[贝内戴蒂]以对阿尔布雷希特·丢勒和Setlio所犯的一个透视错误的急躁回顾,开启了题为“De rationibus operationum perspectivae”的一节,并立即着手证明正确的解法。……这个证明是我们所拥有的第一个完全基于欧几里得的权威、而不诉诸光学的证明(末尾有一处提到Witelo)。
Field在[13]中对贝内戴蒂关于透视法的工作做了彻底研究:-
这部著作[De rationibus operationum perspectivae]确实是一件优雅、严谨且原创的数学作品。前两个品质自然使这部著作对数学家和数学史家具有相当大的吸引力,但在目前的情况下,第三个品质,即这部著作的原创性——或者更确切地说,其原创性的性质——似乎使它值得更广泛的考虑。……这种原创性最重要的方面是,与所有前辈不同,贝内戴蒂将透视构图问题作为三维问题来处理。他总是首先从三维图形出发。这似乎具有回归基本原理的性质。贝内戴蒂已经从艺术家所使用的二维构图,回到了欧几里得光学著作中所考虑的实际物理构型,尽管是以完全几何的方式。……[然而]贝内戴蒂与其说是数学家,不如说是运用几何方法的自然哲学家。这种态度确实也由该著作的标题所暗示:“De rationibus operationum perspectivae”。一个纯粹作为数学家写作的人,肯定会说“theorica”而不是“rationes”吧?
Field还提出了一个有趣的观点,将贝内戴蒂关于透视法的工作与关于音乐的工作进行了比较:-
贝内戴蒂在透视学著作中表现出的态度,即把问题表述为数学物理问题而非纯粹数学问题,与他在音乐著作中表现出的态度相似。
在他的第一部著作中,贝内戴蒂就包含了他关于自由落体的想法,以便能够主张优先权并确保这些想法不被窃取。他一定知道尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚认为吉罗拉莫·卡尔达诺窃取了他对三次方程的解法,尽管在这个例子中吉罗拉莫·卡尔达诺完全承认了尼科洛·塔尔塔利亚的贡献。贝内戴蒂就没有这么幸运了。1562年,Jean Taisner或Taisnier在科隆的Johann Birkmann出版社出版了一部题为Opusculum perpetua memoria dignissimum, de natura magnetis et ejus effectibus, Item de motu continuo的著作。这完全是一部剽窃之作,因为Taisnier将Pierre de Maricourt的Epistola de magnete和贝内戴蒂关于物体下落的论著Demonstratio, 据为己有。具有讽刺意味的是,Taisnier的著作比贝内戴蒂的更为人所知,尤其是在1578年由Richard Eden译成英文之后。西蒙·斯蒂文于1586年发表了他对这一自由落体理论的实验验证,仍然认为该理论实际上出自Taisnier。然而,Taisnier窃取的是贝内戴蒂著作的第一版,西蒙·斯蒂文对其进行了批评,并作出了贝内戴蒂本人在32年前第二版中已经作出的更正。贝内戴蒂直到1570年之后才知道Taisnier窃取了他的著作,在1573年写成的De gnomonum序言中,他表达了自己的愤怒。
贝内戴蒂预言自己将于1592年去世,但在临终之际,他重新计算后说,他最初使用的数据有4分钟的误差[1]:-
贝内戴蒂于1590年初去世。他在最后一部出版著作的末尾几行中预言自己将于1592年去世。临终之际,他重新计算了自己的星象,并宣称原始数据(由Luca Guarico于1552年发表)中必定存在四分钟的误差,从而表明了他终生对司法占星学说的信仰。
Giovanni Benedetti was born into a rich family of high status in Venice and spent his childhood and boyhood in that city. His father was described by Luca Guarico (writing in 1552) as [1]:-
... a Spaniard, philosopher, and physicus, probably in the sense of "student of nature" but possibly meaning "doctor of medicine".
Giovanni was taught philosophy, music and mathematics by his father. From the age of seven onwards he seems to have had no formal education and certainly did not attend a university. Benedetti studied the first four books of Euclid's Elements under Niccolo Fontana, better known as Tartaglia, probably about 1546-1548, although later they seem to have fallen out with each other. We deduce this from the fact that Tartaglia does not mention in his writings that he taught Benedetti, while Benedetti only mentions that he was taught by Tartaglia to "give him his due":-
N Tartaglia taught me only the first four books of Euclid, all the rest I learned by myself with great care and study. Nothing is difficult to him who would be learned.
Certainly during the period that Benedetti was Tartaglia's pupil, Tartaglia was involved the public challenge with Ferrari in which he lost his reputation. This must have had a significant effect on his pupil and, as a consequence, it is not surprising that in Benedetti's later work he is highly critical of Tartaglia's writings. When he was only twenty-two years of age Benedetti wrote Resolutio omnium Euclidis problematum aliorumque ad hoc necessario inventorum una tantummodo circini data apertura which was published in Venice in 1553. In this work he discussed the general solution of all problems in Euclid's Elements, and other geometric problems, using only a compass of fixed opening. It must be significant that the question of proving some of Euclid's theorems with only a compass of fixed opening had been posed by Tartaglia as challenges to Cardan and Ferrari so it is likely that this provided the motivation for Benedetti's study. Benedetti considers the problem:-
Using a pair of compasses with a fixed opening, construct the triangle three sides of which are given such that the sum of two of them is greater than the third.
Having solved this, he uses it to find the points of intersection of two circles of given centres and radii. He then proudly proclaims:-
And I made this construction despite many clever ancient and modern mathematicians who said that this problem was impossible to solve ... I found it on October 15th 1552.
Both Ferrari and Tartaglia produced results on using only a compass of fixed opening but neither produced anything as systematic or of the quality that Benedetti did. In fact Tartaglia's last work was Trattato generale di numeri e misure (1560) on precisely that topic - it is not of the quality of Benedetti's work and, interestingly, does not even mention Benedetti or the Resolutio. There is, however, something else in the Resolutio which is very important but not related in any way to the main subject of the work. This is a dedication in the form of a letter addressed to Gabriel de Guzman, a Spanish Dominican priest with whom he had held discussions in Venice in 1552 on Benedetti's theory of the free fall of bodies. Guzman had suggested that Benedetti publish a mathematical treatment of the speeds of free fall and this letter was his answer to Guzman. Why, one might ask, did he choose to publish this unrelated letter as the dedication in the Resolutio. The answer is that Benedetti feared that his ideas would be stolen if he did not get them into print quickly, so he chose this route. We should note that his fears were fully justified for, as we recount below, despite these attempts his theory was stolen.
What were these ideas of Benedetti on free fall? Well he stated that bodies composed of the same material fell at the same speed regardless of their weight. He justified his claims with an argument using Archimedes' results on bodies in a fluid. Of course at this time Aristotle's views were accepted without question and what Benedetti was putting forward was in complete contradiction to Aristotle. As one might expect those who read Benedetti's work did not accept his ideas. Some argued that they was stupid, other agreed with his findings but said that they must be in agreement with Aristotle. Benedetti himself remarks that he had critics in Rome who said that Aristotle was always right, so his work must be wrong. He answered in critics in his next work Demonstratio proportionum motuum localium contra Aristotelem et omnes philosophos which was published in Venice in 1554. In this he repeated his arguments regarding free fall and showed clearly that what he proposed contradicted Aristotle by quoting those passages in Aristotle's works that it contradicted. Two editions of this work appeared in quick succession, the second containing a modification of his ideas. In this second edition he said that the speed of the falling weight would depend on its surface area because of friction with the air, and only in a vacuum would bodies of different sizes fall at the same speed.
In 1554, the year Benedetti's Demonstratio was published, his daughter was born in Turin. No record of his marriage exists, although no significance should be read into that fact. We do know that he was married in 1585, but it is possible that either this was a second marriage, or that he rejoined his first wife and daughter at this time. Returning to the 1550s, we record Benedetti's appointment as court mathematician to Duke Ottavio Farnese at Parma from 1558 until 1566. At Parma [19]:-
... he performed the duties of a mathematician, astrologer, designer and constructor of sundials, and adviser on the engineering of public works for the duchy.
Benedetti was quite rich so when the Duke failed to pay him for long periods, he was not at all worried financially. By long periods we mean that for one period of ten months and a second period of twenty months, he was not paid. While he was employed at Parma, Benedetti lectured in Rome on the science of Aristotle during the winter of 1559-60 [1]:-
Girolamo Mei, who heard him there, praised his acumen, independence of mind, fluency and memory.
In 1587 Benedetti became ducal mathematician and philosopher, employed by Emanuele Filberto the Duke of Savoy, a post he held until his death. He is also known to have taught in the University of Turin in the first few years after he moved to Turin. Bartolomeo Cristini, professor of mathematics at the University of Turin, wrote the following about Benedetti in 1611 (see for example [19]):-
[Emanuele Filberto] was really so fond of these mathematical arts that he invited from abroad, in order to bring prestige to our University of Turin, all the best and the most expert in those arts and he persuaded them with good salaries. Among them I want to mention Benedetti, who was enormously proficient in mathematical abstractions and left to posterity many excellent works, containing original contributions to every branch of natural philosophy.
Francesco Morosini, the Venetian ambassador to the Court of Savoy, wrote (see for example [19]):-
Since mathematical science is very useful and necessary for the one who intends to practise arms, so His Excellency takes delight in it and his knowledge is much more than passable. Being conscious that a man knows a science so long as he continues to examine and study it, every day he used to listen to a lesson about Euclid or another writer of those sciences from a Venetian Mr Giovanni Battista Benedetti, a man who, not only in my opinion, but also according to the judgement of many expert people, is at present the best in this profession and is greatly appreciated by the Duke because, besides possessing this most excellent science, he is also such a good teacher that each of his pupils becomes very easily competent and expert in it.
Benedetti published De gnomonum umbrarumque solarium liber (1574), a book on sundials. He wrote on the title page that the book is "now first printed for public use and convenience of students." In a letter dedicating the book to Emanuele Filberto, Benedetti wrote:-
Our little book on dialling, Serene Duke, which I drew up in past years, can now at last see the light.
While in Turin he also designed and constructed sundials and fountains. Next he published De temporum emendatione opinio, Augustae Taurinorum (1578) on correcting the calendar. The following year saw his publication of Considerutione di Gio. Battista Benedetti Filosofo del Sereniss. S. Duca di Suvoia in which he contributed to a current dispute concerning the relative volumes of the elements earth and water. His final work, Diversarum Speculationum Mathematicarum et Physicarum Liber Ad Sereniss. Carolum Emunuelem Allobrogum et Subalpinorum ducem invictissimum includes several different pieces written by Benedetti over a number of years. We will discuss below in more detail the important material published here on perspective and music. First we note that Diversarum Speculationum contains a commentary on the Fifth Book of Euclid and a collection of many geometrical theorems including circumscribing a quadrilateral of given sides. In a section on geometry, he also treats spherical triangles, circles and conic sections. There are details of his contributions to isoperimetric figure, regular polygons and regular solids. Dealing with regular polygons, Benedetti proved that Dürer's construction of the regular pentagon using compasses with a fixed opening is not exact.
The Diversarum Speculationum contains a section on mechanics in which Benedetti again attacks Aristotle's physical concepts and also attacks Tartaglia's mechanics. We should note that in this section he claims that if a body is released from circular motion it will travel in a straight line which is a tangent to the original circle of motion. Benedetti should certainly get the credit for being the first to publish such a claim. He also repeats his arguments concerning free fall. He gives the argument that if two bodies of equal weight were dropped, then the same bodies were dropped joined by a thread then, intuitively, the speed of fall would be the same in both cases. Stillman Drake remarks in [1]:-
Benedetti correctly holds that natural rectilinear motion continually increases in speed because of the continual impression of downward impetus, whereas Galileo wrongly believes that acceleration was an accidental and temporary effect at the beginning of free fall only.
Although Galileo had this wrong in De motu, he later realised his mistake and corrected it in later work. We must not give the impression that Benedetti's contributions are better than Galileo's for although he has deeper understanding on some points, he does not attempt to give the mathematical formulation of acceleration which is Galileo's great achievement. In Diversarum Speculationum Benedetti also considers hydrostatic pressure and the idea of hydraulic lift. He correctly claims that winds are due to changes in density of air caused by heating of bodies by the sun in relation to their opacity. He shows that he correctly understands clouds.
We promised to return to his contributions to music. Although this was only published in 1585, the ideas are contained in two letters written to Cipriano da Rore who was choirmaster of the Court of Parma in 1561-62. Benedetti must have held discussions with him during this time, then written the two letters in question in 1563 shortly after da Rore left Parma for Venice. Stillman Drake writes [1]:-
Departing from the prevailing numerical theories of harmony, Benedetti inquired into the relation of pitch, consonance, and rates of vibration. He attributed the generation of musical consonances to the concurrence or codetermination of waves of air. Such waves, resulting from the striking of air by vibrating strings, should either agree with or break in upon one another. Proceeding thus, and asserting that the frequency of vibration of two strings under equal tension vary inversely with the strings lengths, Benedetti proposed an index of agreement obtained by multiplication of the terms of the ratios of a given consonance; by this means he could express the degree of concordance in a mathematical scale.
In [18] these musical contributions described in slightly more technical terms:-
In a letter to the composer Cipriano de Rore of around 1563 the scientist Giambattista Benedetti proposed a new theory of the cause of consonance. Benedetti argued that since sound consists of air waves or vibrations, in the more consonant intervals the shorter more frequent waves concurred with the longer less frequent waves at regular intervals. In the less consonant intervals, on the other hand, concurrence was infrequent and the two sounds did not blend in the ear pleasantly. He showed that in a fifth, for example, the two vibrations will meet every two cycles of the lower note and every three of the higher. He went on to show that in terms of frequency of concurrence the hierarchy of ratios within the octave would be 2:1, 3:2, 4:3, 5:3, 5:4, 6:5, 7:5, 8:5, which challenges both the superiority of super-particular ratios and the sanctity of the senario. There could be no abrupt break from consonance to dissonance but only a continuum of intervals, some more, some less consonant. Benedetti's theory was espoused in the next century by Isaac Beeckman and Marin Mersenne, who sought René Descartes' opinion of it.
Let us now turn to Benedetti's contributions to perspective. In [3] Elkins writes:-
[Benedetti] opens the section titled "De rationibus operationum perspectivae" with an impatient review of a perspective error committed by both Dürer and Setlio, and he proceeds at once to prove the correct solution. ... The proof is the first we possess that is based entirely on the authority of Euclid, without any appeal to optics (there is one reference at the end to Witelo).
Field makes a thorough study of Benedetti's work on perspective in [13]:-
The work [De rationibus operationum perspectivae] is indeed an elegant, rigorous and original piece of mathematics. The first two qualities naturally give the work considerable appeal to mathematicians and historians of mathematics, but in the present case the third quality, the work's originality - or rather the nature of its originality - seems to entitle it to a wider consideration. ... the most important aspect of this originality is that unlike all his predecessors Benedetti treats the problem of perspective construction as three-dimensional. He works always from the three-dimensional diagram in the first instance. This seems to be in the nature of a return to first principles. Benedetti has returned from the two-dimensional constructions used by artists to the actual physical configurations considered, albeit in a completely geometrical manner, in Euclid's work on Optics. ... [However] Benedetti is not so much a mathematician as a natural philosopher employing the methods of geometry. This attitude is, indeed, also suggested by the title of the work: 'De rationibus operationum perspectivae'. Surely a mathematician writing purely as such would have spoken of 'theorica' rather than 'rationes'?
Field also makes an interesting point comparing Benedetti's work on perspective with that on music:-
The attitude Benedetti shows in his work on perspective, which is to formulate the problem as one of mathematical physics rather than of mathematics proper, is similar to the attitude he shows in his work on music.
In his very first work Benedetti included his ideas on free fall so that he could claim priority and ensure the ideas were not stolen. He must have been aware that Tartaglia considered that Cardan had stolen his solution of the cubic, although in this case Cardan fully acknowledged Tartaglia's contributions. Benedetti was not so lucky. In 1562 Jean Taisner or Taisnier published from the press of Johann Birkmann of Cologne a work entitled Opusculum perpetua memoria dignissimum, de natura magnetis et ejus effectibus, Item de motu continuo. This is totally a piece of plagiarism, for Taisnier claims as his own the Epistola de magnete of Pierre de Maricourt and the Demonstratio, the treatise on the fall of bodies by Benedetti. Now, ironically, Taisnier's work became better known than that of Benedetti, particularly after it was translated into English by Richard Eden in 1578. Simon Stevin published his experimental verification of this theory of free fall in 1586, still believing that the theory was really due to Taisnier. However, Taisnier had stolen the first edition of Benedetti's work and Stevin criticised it, making the correction that Benedetti had made himself in his second edition 32 years earlier. Benedetti was not aware that Taisnier had stolen his work until after 1570 and in the Preface of De gnomonum, written in 1573, he voiced his anger.
Benedetti forecast his death for 1592 but, on his deathbed, he recalculated saying that the original data he used was 4 minutes in error [1]:-
Benedetti died early in 1590. He had forecast his death for 1592 in the final lines of his last published book. On his deathbed he recomputed his horoscope and declared that an error of four minutes must have been made in the original data (published in 1552 by Luca Guarico), thus evincing his lifelong faith in the doctrines of judiciary astrology.
正文里的方括号编号指向这里,悬停即可直接看到条目。书目保留原文——译了书名反而查不到文献。
原站列出的延伸阅读与外部数据库,照原样保留,目标多为英文页面。
关于乔万尼·巴蒂斯塔·贝内戴蒂的其它网站:
原站的交叉引用。指向本站已镜像专题的留在站内,其余仍指回原站。